I'm new to working with PDDL. I use an online editor. I have this problem: there are 3 agents, 3 cannibals and a boat with its maximum capacity of 2 people. There are also 2 shores and a river between them. All of the people are on one shore initially. There can't be more cannibals than agents on a shore and I need to find a way to move all of them to the other shore.
When I tried to solve it I got this error:
"Suspected timeout. arity of VALID_STATE to high! increase MAX_ARITY (currently 5)"
I would really appreciate it if someone could find what I did wrong or at least tell me more about this error and how to solve it.
This is the problem:
(define (problem traversare)
(:domain problema1)
(:objects stg dr)
(:init
(current_position stg stg stg stg stg stg)
(valid_state stg stg stg stg stg stg)
(valid_state dr dr dr stg stg stg)
(valid_state stg stg stg dr dr stg)
(valid_state dr dr stg dr dr stg)
(valid_state dr stg dr dr dr stg)
(valid_state stg dr dr dr dr stg)
(valid_state dr dr dr dr dr stg)
(valid_state stg stg stg dr stg dr)
(valid_state dr dr stg dr stg dr)
(valid_state dr stg dr dr stg dr)
(valid_state stg dr dr dr stg dr)
(valid_state dr dr dr dr stg dr)
(valid_state stg stg stg stg dr dr)
(valid_state dr dr stg stg dr dr)
(valid_state dr stg dr stg dr dr)
(valid_state stg dr dr stg dr dr)
(valid_state dr dr dr stg dr dr)
(valid_state stg stg stg stg stg dr)
(valid_state dr stg stg stg stg dr)
(valid_state stg dr stg stg stg dr)
(valid_state stg stg dr stg stg dr)
(valid_state dr dr dr stg stg dr)
(valid_state stg stg stg stg dr stg)
(valid_state dr stg stg stg dr stg)
(valid_state stg dr stg stg dr stg)
(valid_state stg stg dr stg dr stg)
(valid_state dr dr dr stg dr stg)
(valid_state stg stg stg dr stg stg)
(valid_state dr stg stg dr stg stg)
(valid_state stg dr stg dr stg stg)
(valid_state stg stg dr dr stg stg)
(valid_state dr dr dr dr stg stg)
(valid_state dr dr dr dr dr dr)
)
(:goal
(current_position dr dr dr dr dr dr))
)
Here I've written all the possible states given the requirements of the exercise.
And this is the domain:
(define (domain problema1)
(:predicates
(current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
)
(:action moveM1SD
:parameters (?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM2SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM3SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveC1SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveC2SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)))
)
(:action moveC3SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)))
)
(:action moveM1DS
:parameters (?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM2DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM3DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveC1DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveC2DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)))
)
(:action moveC3DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)
)
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)))
)
(:action moveM1M2SD
:parameters (?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position stg stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state dr dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position dr dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position stg stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM1M3SD
:parameters (?m2 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position stg ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state dr ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position dr ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position stg ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM1C1SD
:parameters (?m2 ?m3 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state dr ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM1C2SD
:parameters (?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)
(valid_state dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)
(not (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM1C3SD
:parameters (?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)
(valid_state dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr))
:effect (and (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)
(not (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)))
)
(:action moveM2M3SD
:parameters (?m1 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 stg stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 dr dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 dr dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 stg stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM2C1SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m3 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 dr ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM2C2SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m3 ?c1 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM2C3SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)
(valid_state ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)
(not (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)))
)
(:action moveM3C1SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg stg ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 dr dr ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr dr ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg stg ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM3C2SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?c1 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 stg ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 dr ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 dr ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 stg ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM3C3SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?c1 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 stg)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 dr))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 dr)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 stg)))
)
(:action moveC1C2SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg stg ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr dr ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr dr ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg stg ?c3)))
)
(:action moveC1C3SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 stg)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 dr))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 dr)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 stg)))
)
(:action moveC2C3SD
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg stg)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr dr))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr dr)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg stg)))
)
(:action moveM1M2DS
:parameters (?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position dr dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state stg stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position stg stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position dr dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM1M3DS
:parameters (?m2 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position dr ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state stg ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position stg ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position dr ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM1C1DS
:parameters (?m2 ?m3 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state stg ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM1C2DS
:parameters (?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)
(valid_state stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)
(not (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM1C3DS
:parameters (?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)
(valid_state stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg))
:effect (and (current_position stg ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)
(not (current_position dr ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)))
)
(:action moveM2M3DS
:parameters (?m1 ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 dr dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 stg stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 stg stg ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 dr dr ?c1 ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM2C1DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m3 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 stg ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 stg ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 dr ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM2C2DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m3 ?c1 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 stg ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 dr ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM2C3DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m3 ?c1 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)
(valid_state ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 stg ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 stg)
(not (current_position ?m1 dr ?m3 ?c1 ?c2 dr)))
)
(:action moveM3C1DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?c2 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr dr ?c2 ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 stg stg ?c2 ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg stg ?c2 ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr dr ?c2 ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM3C2DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?c1 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 dr ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 stg ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 stg ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 dr ?c3)))
)
(:action moveM3C3DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?c1 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 dr)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 stg))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 stg ?c1 ?c2 stg)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 dr ?c1 ?c2 dr)))
)
(:action moveC1C2DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c3)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr dr ?c3)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg stg ?c3))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg stg ?c3)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr dr ?c3)))
)
(:action moveC1C3DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c2)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 dr)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 stg))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 stg ?c2 stg)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 dr ?c2 dr)))
)
(:action moveC2C3DS
:parameters (?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1)
:precondition (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr dr)
(valid_state ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg stg))
:effect (and (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 stg stg)
(not (current_position ?m1 ?m2 ?m3 ?c1 dr dr)))
)
)
Here I defined all the possible actions, including:
every person can cross the river alone from one shore to the other.
every person can cross the river with someone else from one shore to the other.
I've made these notations:
moveXSD is when someone is crossing the river from left to right alone on the boat
moveXYSD is when someone is crossing the river from left to right with another person
moveXSD is when someone is crossing the river from left to right alone on the boat
moveXYDS is when someone is crossing the river from right to left with another personmoveXSD is when someone is crossing the river from left to right alone on the boat
moveXYDS is when someone is crossing the river from right to left with another person
m1 m2 m3 are the agents and c1 c2 c3 are the cannibals
stg stands for left
dr stands for right
Considering the fact that I just started using this programming language, I hope I've made no newbie mistakes. Please, let me know if I missed something, or haven't given you all the details needed.
The error message is saying that you are using an action with too many parameters. You'll need to find a way to reduce it to 5 arguments max, or use a different planner.
Related
For every sosa:FeatureOfInterest (room), get the lowest temperature per day from the associated sensors for that room. There are 100 rooms. Each room has 3 sensors. The timeframe is one year.
Goal: Query to select lowest temperature per day per room from group of sensors plus time of day when the temperature occurred.
Example data (N3):
prefix rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns>
prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#>
prefix sosa: <http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/>
prefix xsd: <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#>
prefix ex: <http://www.example.com/>
# Room FOIs
ex:room1Foi a sosa:FeatureOfInterest .
# ...
ex:room100Foi a sosa:FeatureOfInterest .
# Room 1 sensor observations 1/1/2021
ex:obs1Room1 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room1Foi ;
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-01T00:00:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "51.4"^^xsd:decimal .
ex:obs2Room1 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room1Foi .
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-01T08:00:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "50.2"^^xsd:decimal .
ex:obs3Room1 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room1Foi .
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-01T:16:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "49.8"^^xsd:decimal .
# Room 1 sensor observations 1/2/2021
ex:obs4Room1 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room1Foi ;
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-02T00:00:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "61.4"^^xsd:decimal .
ex:obs5Room1 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room1Foi .
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-02T08:00:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "60.2"^^xsd:decimal .
ex:obs6Room1 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room1Foi .
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-02T:16:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "59.8"^^xsd:decimal .
# ...
# Room 100 sensor observations 1/1/2021
ex:obs1Room100 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room100Foi ;
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-01T00:00:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "50.7"^^xsd:decimal .
ex:obs2Room100 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room100Foi .
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-01T08:00:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "51.6"^^xsd:decimal .
ex:obs3Room100 a sosa:Observation .
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ex:room100Foi .
sosa:resultTime "2021-01-01T:16:00"^^xsd:dateTime ;
sosa:observedProperty "TEMP"^^xsd:string ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult "48.0"^^xsd:decimal .
# Room 1 sensor observations 1/2/2021
# ...
One attempt:
prefix rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns>
prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#>
prefix sosa: <http://www.w3.org/ns/sosa/>
prefix xsd: <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#>
prefix ex: <http://www.example1.com/>
select ?oFoi ?day min(?val) as ?minTemp ?time where {
{select ?f where {
?f a sosa:FeatureOfInterest .
}}
?o a sosa:Observation ;
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ?oFoi ;
sosa:resultTime ?time ;
sosa:observedProperty ?p ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult ?val .
filter(?oFoi = ?f) .
bind(day(?t) as ?day) .
} group by ?oFoi ?day ?time
order by desc(?oFoi) asc(?day)
Result:
oFoi
day
minTemp
time
http://www.example.com/room1Foi
1
51.4
2021-01-01 0:00:00
http://www.example.com/room1Foi
1
50.2
2021-01-01 8:00:00
http://www.example.com/room1Foi
1
49.8
2021-01-01 16:00:00
http://www.example.com/room1Foi
2
59.8
2021-01-02 16:00:00
http://www.example.com/room1Foi
2
60.2
2021-01-02 8:00:00
http://www.example.com/room1Foi
2
61.4
2021-01-02 0:00:00
...
...
...
...
This doesn't work because ?time must be included in the group by clause. Removing ?time from group by clause will return the correct rows. However, ?time is necessary to be included.
Ideal result:
oFoi
day
minTemp
time
http://www.example.com/room1Foi
1
49.8
2021-01-01 16:00:00
http://www.example.com/room1Foi
2
59.8
2021-01-02 16:00:00
...
...
...
...
Update:
This gets closer but still is including multiple results when two times in the same day have the same temperature (both results included):
select ?o2 ?oFoi2 ?day2 ?val2 sample(?t2) as ?tx2 ?p2 where {
?o2 a sosa:Observation ;
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ?oFoi2 ;
sosa:resultTime ?t2 ;
sosa:observedProperty ?p2 ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult ?val2 .
bind(day(?t2) as ?day2) .
filter(?oFoi2 = ?oFoi) .
filter(?day2 = ?day) .
filter(?val2 = ?vx) .
{select ?oFoi ?day min(?val) as ?vx where {
{select ?f where {
?f a sosa:FeatureOfInterest .
}}
?o a sosa:Observation ;
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ?oFoi ;
sosa:resultTime ?t ;
sosa:observedProperty ?p ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult ?val .
filter(?oFoi = ?f) .
bind(day(?t) as ?day) .
} group by ?oFoi ?day
order by desc(?oFoi) asc(?day)
}
} group by ?o2 ?oFoi2 ?day2 ?p2 ?val2
Result:
o2
oFoi2
day2
val2
tx2
p2
http://www.example3.com/obs3Room100
http://www.example3.com/room100Foi
1
48
2021-01-01 16:00:00
"TEMP"^^http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string
http://www.example3.com/obs6Room1
http://www.example3.com/room1Foi
2
59.8
2021-01-02 16:00:00
"TEMP"^^http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string
http://www.example3.com/obs333Room1
http://www.example3.com/room1Foi
1
-9.8
2021-01-01 16:00:00
"aTEMP"^^http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string
http://www.example3.com/obs33Room1
http://www.example3.com/room1Foi
1
-9.8
2021-01-01 7:59:00
"aTEMP"^^http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string
...
...
...
...
...
...
Oops: ?o2 is unnecessary and removing it from the above query results in the correct solution.
Adding an outer select appears to solve this. Using an aggregate for the time such as min(), max(), avg(), sample(), etc. are all valid approaches for aggregating the time variable. (Adding an extra property aTEMP to help in understanding.)
Query:
select ?oFoi2 ?day2 ?val2 sample(?t2) as ?tx2 ?p2 where {
?o2 a sosa:Observation ;
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ?oFoi2 ;
sosa:resultTime ?t2 ;
sosa:observedProperty ?p2 ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult ?val2 .
bind(day(?t2) as ?day2) .
filter(?oFoi2 = ?oFoi) .
filter(?day2 = ?day) .
filter(?val2 = ?vx) .
{select ?oFoi ?day min(?val) as ?vx where {
{select ?f where {
?f a sosa:FeatureOfInterest .
}}
?o a sosa:Observation ;
sosa:hasFeatureOfInterest ?oFoi ;
sosa:resultTime ?t ;
sosa:observedProperty ?p ;
sosa:hasSimpleResult ?val .
filter(?oFoi = ?f) .
bind(day(?t) as ?day) .
} group by ?oFoi ?day
order by desc(?oFoi) asc(?day)
}
} group by ?oFoi2 ?day2 ?p2 ?val2
Result:
oFoi2
day2
val2
tx2
p2
http://www.example3.com/room100Foi
1
48
2021-01-01 16:00:00
"TEMP"^^http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string
http://www.example3.com/room1Foi
2
59.8
2021-01-02 16:00:00
"TEMP"^^http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string
http://www.example3.com/room1Foi
1
-9.8
2021-01-01 7:59:00
"aTEMP"^^http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#string
...
...
...
...
...
I have the following Data Graph.
#prefix hr: <http://learningsparql.com/ns/humanResources#> .
#prefix rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#> .
#prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
#prefix sch: <http://schema.org/> .
#prefix xml: <http://www.w3.org/XML/1998/namespace> .
#prefix xsd: <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#> .
hr:Another a rdfs:Class .
hr:Employee a rdfs:Class ;
rdfs:label "model" ;
rdfs:comment "a good employee" .
hr:Longer a hr:Employee ;
rdfs:label "model" ;
rdfs:comment "a good employee" .
hr:freestanding a rdf:Property ;
sch:rangeIncludes sch:Text .
hr:missing rdfs:comment "some comment about missing" .
hr:name a rdf:Property ;
sch:domainIncludes hr:Employee .
hr:nosuper a rdf:Property ;
sch:domainIncludes hr:Uncreated ;
sch:rangeIncludes sch:Text .
hr:randomtype a hr:invalidtype ;
rdfs:label "some label about randomtype" ;
rdfs:comment "some comment about randomtype" .
hr:typo a rdfs:Classs ;
rdfs:label "some label about typo" ;
rdfs:comment "some comment about typo" .
I am trying to understand the difference between these two Shape Graphs, which I think (wrongly!) should return the same result...validation errors for hr:typo, hr:randomtype, and hr:missing because there is no rdf:type property path to either rdfs:Class or rdf:Property.
The following Shape Graph produces the expected validation errors.
(A) -- good results
#prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
#prefix rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#> .
#prefix sch: <http://schema.org/> .
#prefix sh: <http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#> .
#prefix ex: <http://example.org/> .
ex:ClassShape
a sh:NodeShape ;
sh:property [
sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ];
sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ;
sh:hasValue rdfs:Class;
sh:message "class" ;
] .
ex:PropertyShape
a sh:NodeShape ;
sh:property [
sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ];
sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ;
sh:hasValue rdf:Property;
sh:message "property" ;
] .
ex:ClassOrProperty
a sh:NodeShape ;
sh:target [
a sh:SPARQLTarget ;
sh:select """
SELECT ?this
WHERE {
?this ?p ?o .
}
""" ;
] ;
sh:or (
ex:ClassShape
ex:PropertyShape
);
.
The good and expected validation errors produced by (A) are:
Validation Report
Conforms: False
Results (3):
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: ex:ClassOrProperty
Focus Node: hr:randomtype
Value Node: hr:randomtype
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: ex:ClassOrProperty
Focus Node: hr:typo
Value Node: hr:typo
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: ex:ClassOrProperty
Focus Node: hr:missing
Value Node: hr:missing
However, this Shape Graph:
(B) -- bad results
#prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
#prefix rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#> .
#prefix sch: <http://schema.org/> .
#prefix sh: <http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#> .
#prefix ex: <http://example.org/> .
ex:ClassOrProperty
a sh:NodeShape ;
sh:target [
a sh:SPARQLTarget ;
sh:select """
SELECT ?this
WHERE {
?this ?p ?o .
}
""" ;
] ;
sh:property [
sh:path [sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type] ;
sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ;
sh:or (
[ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class; ]
[ sh:hasValue rdf:Property; ]
)
];
.
does not produce only the expected validation errors. I get:
Validation Report
Conforms: False
Results (12):
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:freestanding
Value Node: hr:freestanding
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:name
Value Node: hr:name
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:Another
Value Node: hr:Another
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:nosuper
Value Node: hr:nosuper
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:Employee
Value Node: hr:Employee
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:randomtype
Value Node: hr:randomtype
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:randomtype
Value Node: hr:invalidtype
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:typo
Value Node: hr:typo
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:typo
Value Node: rdfs:Classs
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:missing
Value Node: hr:missing
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:Longer
Value Node: hr:Employee
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Constraint Violation in OrConstraintComponent (http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#OrConstraintComponent):
Severity: sh:Violation
Source Shape: [ sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ; sh:or ( [ sh:hasValue rdfs:Class ] [ sh:hasValue rdf:Property ] ) ; sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ] ]
Focus Node: hr:Longer
Value Node: hr:Longer
Result Path: [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ]
Why are the results different?
The reason why I liked (B) over (A) is because it would have been more concise, if it had worked.
Both pySHACL and TopBraid SHACL API shaclvalidate.sh agree on the results.
It is important to understand how property paths work. A path is used to reach values. When using sh:path [sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:path] and considering the node hr:Longer, it will reach three values -- (0) hr:Longer, (1) hr:Employee, and (2) rdfs:Class.
With this concept firmly in mind, what is going on in (B) and why it does not work can be fully explained.
Both (A) and (B) have the same target definition and will return the same focus nodes. These are:
hr:Another
hr:Employee
hr:Longer
hr:freestanding
hr:missing
hr:name
hr:nosuper
hr:randomtype
hr:typo
Additionally, common to both (A) and (B) is sh:path [sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type] ;. When considering the node hr:Longer, for example, it will emit three values, each of which may need to be checked. These three values are (0) hr:Longer, (1) hr:Employee, and (2) rdfs:Class.
For (B), when it considers hr:Longer and passes emitted value hr:Longer to sh:or, it see that it is not either a rdfs:Class or rdf:Property. A validation error is emitted because neither clause of sh:or was satisfied.
To make (B) work, the two clauses in the sh:or need to be changed to [ sh:path [sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type] ; sh:hasValue rdfs:Class; ] and [ sh:path [sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type] ; sh:hasValue rdf:Property; ]. In this case, when hr:Longer is passed into the sh:or, each clause checks the entire path and sh:hasValue only requires that one of the three values emitted by the path matches.
(B) - Working
#prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
#prefix rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#> .
#prefix sch: <http://schema.org/> .
#prefix sh: <http://www.w3.org/ns/shacl#> .
#prefix ex: <http://example.org/> .
ex:ClassOrProperty
a sh:NodeShape ;
sh:target [
a sh:SPARQLTarget ;
sh:select """
SELECT ?this
WHERE {
?this ?p ?o .
}
""" ;
] ;
sh:property [
sh:path [sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type] ;
sh:nodeKind sh:IRI ;
sh:or (
[ sh:path [sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type] ; sh:hasValue rdfs:Class; ]
[ sh:path [sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type] ; sh:hasValue rdf:Property; ]
)
];
.
Now considering (A), each focus node is passed to ex:PropertyShape and ex:ClassShape. If it validates against one of the shapes, it will validate. Both shapes are similar in that they each use the path sh:path [ sh:zeroOrMorePath rdf:type ];. Because they use sh:hasValue, only one of the emitted values for the path needs to match. Considering hr:Longer again, because the path will emit the value rdfs:Class, it validates against ex:ClassShape and no validation error is generated.
I need some help, I am new to SPARQL. I got stuck in this query I have to build, in which I have to get all musicians that have participed in a song with all 4 Beatles (excluding Uncredited as a possible answer).
What I have donw until now, but I am not really sure it is correct.
SELECT ?musicianName ?songTitle ?role
WHERE {
?song ?role ?musician .
?song rdfs:label ?songTitle .
?musician rdfs:label ?musicianName .
FILTER (?musician NOT IN ("John Lennon", "Paul McCartney", "George Harrison", "Ringo Starr", "Uncredited"))
}
The data file is below:
Data File (Beatles.ttl)
#prefix c: <http://beatlesExample/ns/class/> .
#prefix t: <http://beatlesExample/ns/title/> .
#prefix pi: <http://beatlesExample/ns/playsInstrument/> .
#prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
#prefix m: <http://beatlesExample/ns/musician/> .
t:MagicalMysteryTour a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Magical Mystery Tour" ;
pi:acousticrhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:percussion m:RingoStarr , m:NeilAspinall , m:MalEvans , m:GeorgeHarrison , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:piano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:trumpet m:ElgarHowarth , m:JohnWilbraham , m:DavidMason , m:RoyCopestake ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney , m:GeorgeHarrison .
t:PennyLane a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Penny Lane" ;
pi:acousticguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:backingvocals m:JohnLennon , m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:bassguitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:doublebass m:FrankClarke ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:electricguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:flutesorpiccolos m:PGoody , m:RaySwinfield , m:MannyWinters , m:DennisWalton ;
pi:guitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:handclaps m:GeorgeHarrison , m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:harmonium m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:oboesorcoranglais m:DickMorgan , m:MikeWinfield ;
pi:piano m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:tambourine m:RingoStarr ;
pi:trumpetsorflugelhorn m:FreddyClayton , m:LeonCalvert , m:BertCourtley , m:DuncanCampbell , m:DavidMason ;
pi:tubularbells m:RingoStarr ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:NotASecondTime a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Not A Second Time" ;
pi:acousticrhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:piano m:GeorgeMartin ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:Yesterday a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Yesterday" ;
pi:cello m:FranciscoGabarro ;
pi:guitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:viola m:KennethEssex ;
pi:violin m:TonyGilbert , m:SidneySax ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:LosParanoias a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Los Paranoias" ;
pi:acousticguitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:percussion m:JohnLennon ;
pi:shaker m:RingoStarr ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:LikeDreamersDo a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Like Dreamers Do" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:PeteBest ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:IGotToFindMyBaby a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "I Got To Find My Baby" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:harmonica m:JohnLennon ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:Revolution1 a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Revolution 1" ;
pi:Hammondorgan m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:acousticguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:backingvocals m:FrancieSchwartz , m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:piano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:trombone m:JPower , m:DonLang , m:BillPovey , m:RexMorris ;
pi:trumpet m:FreddyClayton , m:DerekWatkins ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:DizzyMissLizzy a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Dizzy Miss Lizzy" ;
pi:Hammondorgan m:JohnLennon ;
pi:HohnerPianetelectricpiano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:cowbell m:RingoStarr ;
pi:double-trackedleadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:YesItIs a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Yes It Is" ;
pi:acousticrhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:harmonyvocals m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:tambourine m:RingoStarr ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:IWannaBeYourMan a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "I Wanna Be Your Man" ;
pi:Hammondorgan m:GeorgeMartin ;
pi:backingvocals m:PaulMcCartney , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:maracas m:RingoStarr ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:RingoStarr .
t:ThingsWeSaidToday a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Things We Said Today" ;
pi:acousticrhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:piano m:JohnLennon ;
pi:tambourine m:RingoStarr ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:HallelujahILoveHerSo
a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Hallelujah, I Love Her So" ;
pi:bass m:StuartSutcliffe ;
pi:guitar m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:OldBrownShoe a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Old Brown Shoe" ;
pi:backingvocals m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:bass m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:guitar m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:organ m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:piano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:vocals m:GeorgeHarrison .
t:GoodNight a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Good Night" ;
pi:12violins m:Uncredited ;
pi:backingvocals m:MikeRedway , m:PatWhitmore , m:FredLucas , m:ValStockwell , m:IreneKing , m:IngridThomas , m:KenBarrie , m:RossGilmour ;
pi:celesta m:GeorgeMartin ;
pi:clarinet m:Uncredited ;
pi:doublebass m:Uncredited ;
pi:harp m:Uncredited ;
pi:horn m:Uncredited ;
pi:threecellos m:Uncredited ;
pi:threeflutes m:Uncredited ;
pi:threeviolas m:Uncredited ;
pi:vibraphone m:Uncredited ;
pi:vocals m:RingoStarr .
t:MemphisTennessee a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Memphis, Tennessee" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:TicketToRide a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Ticket To Ride" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:double-trackedleadvocals m:JohnLennon ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:handclaps m:RingoStarr ;
pi:harmonyvocals m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:leadguitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:GeorgeHarrison , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:tambourine m:RingoStarr .
t:Ob-La-DiOb-La-Da a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da" ;
pi:acousticguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:backingvocals m:JohnLennon , m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:bongo m:RingoStarr ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:handclaps m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney , m:GeorgeHarrison , m:RingoStarr ;
pi:percussion m:RingoStarr ;
pi:piano m:JohnLennon ;
pi:threesaxophones m:Uncredited ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:LetItBe a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Let It Be" ;
pi:backingvocals m:JohnLennon , m:LindaMcCartney , m:PaulMcCartney , m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:bassguitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:cello m:Uncredited ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:electricpiano m:BillyPreston ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:maracas m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:organ m:BillyPreston ;
pi:piano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:tenorsaxophone m:Uncredited ;
pi:twotrombones m:Uncredited ;
pi:twotrumpets m:Uncredited ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:IGotAWoman a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "I Got A Woman" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:TheSaints a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "The Saints" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:PeteBest ;
pi:leadguitar m:TonySheridan , m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:TonySheridan .
t:LendMeYourComb a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Lend Me Your Comb" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney , m:JohnLennon .
t:BesameMucho a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Besame Mucho" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:PeteBest ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
I am in need of some help regarding SPARQL construct queries. How is it possible to make a CONSTRUCT query with an IF condition to get triples that enable rules representation?
Like a CONSTRUCT query that enables us to express the following rules:
If X is an instance of a C1 class, and C1 is a subclass of a C2 class, then X is an instance of C2.
and
If X has in P1 property the value V, and P1 is a subproperty of P2, then X has in property P2 the value V.
For this Data File (Beatles.ttl)
#prefix c: <http://beatlesExample/ns/class/> .
#prefix t: <http://beatlesExample/ns/title/> .
#prefix pi: <http://beatlesExample/ns/playsInstrument/> .
#prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
#prefix m: <http://beatlesExample/ns/musician/> .
t:MagicalMysteryTour a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Magical Mystery Tour" ;
pi:acousticrhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:percussion m:RingoStarr , m:NeilAspinall , m:MalEvans , m:GeorgeHarrison , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:piano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:trumpet m:ElgarHowarth , m:JohnWilbraham , m:DavidMason , m:RoyCopestake ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney , m:GeorgeHarrison .
t:PennyLane a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Penny Lane" ;
pi:acousticguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:backingvocals m:JohnLennon , m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:bassguitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:doublebass m:FrankClarke ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:electricguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:flutesorpiccolos m:PGoody , m:RaySwinfield , m:MannyWinters , m:DennisWalton ;
pi:guitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:handclaps m:GeorgeHarrison , m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:harmonium m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:oboesorcoranglais m:DickMorgan , m:MikeWinfield ;
pi:piano m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:tambourine m:RingoStarr ;
pi:trumpetsorflugelhorn m:FreddyClayton , m:LeonCalvert , m:BertCourtley , m:DuncanCampbell , m:DavidMason ;
pi:tubularbells m:RingoStarr ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:NotASecondTime a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Not A Second Time" ;
pi:acousticrhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:piano m:GeorgeMartin ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:Yesterday a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Yesterday" ;
pi:cello m:FranciscoGabarro ;
pi:guitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:viola m:KennethEssex ;
pi:violin m:TonyGilbert , m:SidneySax ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:LosParanoias a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Los Paranoias" ;
pi:acousticguitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:percussion m:JohnLennon ;
pi:shaker m:RingoStarr ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:LikeDreamersDo a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Like Dreamers Do" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:PeteBest ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:IGotToFindMyBaby a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "I Got To Find My Baby" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:harmonica m:JohnLennon ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:Revolution1 a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Revolution 1" ;
pi:Hammondorgan m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:acousticguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:backingvocals m:FrancieSchwartz , m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:piano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:trombone m:JPower , m:DonLang , m:BillPovey , m:RexMorris ;
pi:trumpet m:FreddyClayton , m:DerekWatkins ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:DizzyMissLizzy a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Dizzy Miss Lizzy" ;
pi:Hammondorgan m:JohnLennon ;
pi:HohnerPianetelectricpiano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:cowbell m:RingoStarr ;
pi:double-trackedleadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:YesItIs a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Yes It Is" ;
pi:acousticrhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:harmonyvocals m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:tambourine m:RingoStarr ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:IWannaBeYourMan a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "I Wanna Be Your Man" ;
pi:Hammondorgan m:GeorgeMartin ;
pi:backingvocals m:PaulMcCartney , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:maracas m:RingoStarr ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:RingoStarr .
t:ThingsWeSaidToday a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Things We Said Today" ;
pi:acousticrhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:piano m:JohnLennon ;
pi:tambourine m:RingoStarr ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:HallelujahILoveHerSo
a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Hallelujah, I Love Her So" ;
pi:bass m:StuartSutcliffe ;
pi:guitar m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:OldBrownShoe a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Old Brown Shoe" ;
pi:backingvocals m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:bass m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:guitar m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:organ m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:piano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:vocals m:GeorgeHarrison .
t:GoodNight a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Good Night" ;
pi:12violins m:Uncredited ;
pi:backingvocals m:MikeRedway , m:PatWhitmore , m:FredLucas , m:ValStockwell , m:IreneKing , m:IngridThomas , m:KenBarrie , m:RossGilmour ;
pi:celesta m:GeorgeMartin ;
pi:clarinet m:Uncredited ;
pi:doublebass m:Uncredited ;
pi:harp m:Uncredited ;
pi:horn m:Uncredited ;
pi:threecellos m:Uncredited ;
pi:threeflutes m:Uncredited ;
pi:threeviolas m:Uncredited ;
pi:vibraphone m:Uncredited ;
pi:vocals m:RingoStarr .
t:MemphisTennessee a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Memphis, Tennessee" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:TicketToRide a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Ticket To Ride" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:double-trackedleadvocals m:JohnLennon ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:handclaps m:RingoStarr ;
pi:harmonyvocals m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:leadguitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:GeorgeHarrison , m:JohnLennon ;
pi:tambourine m:RingoStarr .
t:Ob-La-DiOb-La-Da a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Ob-La-Di, Ob-La-Da" ;
pi:acousticguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:backingvocals m:JohnLennon , m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:bongo m:RingoStarr ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:handclaps m:JohnLennon , m:PaulMcCartney , m:GeorgeHarrison , m:RingoStarr ;
pi:percussion m:RingoStarr ;
pi:piano m:JohnLennon ;
pi:threesaxophones m:Uncredited ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:LetItBe a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Let It Be" ;
pi:backingvocals m:JohnLennon , m:LindaMcCartney , m:PaulMcCartney , m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:bassguitar m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:cello m:Uncredited ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:electricpiano m:BillyPreston ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:maracas m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:organ m:BillyPreston ;
pi:piano m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:tenorsaxophone m:Uncredited ;
pi:twotrombones m:Uncredited ;
pi:twotrumpets m:Uncredited ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
t:IGotAWoman a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "I Got A Woman" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:JohnLennon .
t:TheSaints a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "The Saints" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:PeteBest ;
pi:leadguitar m:TonySheridan , m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:TonySheridan .
t:LendMeYourComb a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Lend Me Your Comb" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:RingoStarr ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:GeorgeHarrison , m:PaulMcCartney , m:JohnLennon .
t:BesameMucho a c:Song ;
rdfs:label "Besame Mucho" ;
pi:bass m:PaulMcCartney ;
pi:drums m:PeteBest ;
pi:leadguitar m:GeorgeHarrison ;
pi:rhythmguitar m:JohnLennon ;
pi:vocals m:PaulMcCartney .
As suggested in the comments: you don't actually need a conditional to express this. All you're doing in the left-hand side of the rule is matching a combination of triple patterns. This is exactly what the WHERE clause in a SPARQL query does. Similarly, the right-hand side of the rule simply recombines matched resources into new triple patterns - this is exactly what the CONSTRUCT clause does. For example:
If X is an instance of a C1 class, and C1 is a subclass of a C2 class, then X is an instance of C2.
That could be expressed as:
CONSTRUCT { ?X a ?C2 }
WHERE { ?X a ?C1. ?C1 rdfs:subClassOf+ ?C2 }
Similarly:
If X has in P1 property the value V, and P1 is a subproperty of P2, then X has in property P2 the value V.
could be expressed as:
CONSTRUCT { ?X ?P2 ?V }
WHERE { ?X ?P1 ?V . ?P1 rdfs:subPropertyOf+ ?P2 }
That's all you need.
[EDIT]
I have this RDF :
#prefix : <http://www.x.com/ontology#> .
#prefix rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#> .
#prefix owl: <http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#> .
#prefix xsd: <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#> .
#prefix rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#> .
#prefix ontology: <http://www.x.com/ontology/> .
<http://www.x.com/ontology>
a owl:Ontology .
ontology:melalui_jalur
a owl:ObjectProperty .
ontology:memiliki_peminat
a owl:ObjectProperty .
ontology:alias a owl:DatatypeProperty .
ontology:jumlah a owl:DatatypeProperty .
ontology:nama a owl:DatatypeProperty .
ontology:tahun a owl:DatatypeProperty .
ontology:Jalur_Terima
a owl:Class ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:string ;
owl:onProperty ontology:alias
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:string ;
owl:onProperty ontology:nama
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:string ;
owl:onProperty ontology:alias
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:string ;
owl:onProperty ontology:nama
] .
ontology:Peminat a owl:Class ;
rdfs:subClassOf ontology:Penerimaan ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:int ;
owl:onProperty ontology:jumlah
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:int ;
owl:onProperty ontology:tahun
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:int ;
owl:onProperty ontology:jumlah
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:int ;
owl:onProperty ontology:tahun
] .
ontology:Penerimaan a owl:Class ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:onProperty ontology:melalui_jalur ;
owl:someValuesFrom ontology:Jalur_Terima
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:onProperty ontology:melalui_jalur ;
owl:someValuesFrom ontology:Jalur_Terima
] .
ontology:Prodi a owl:Class ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:onProperty ontology:memiliki_peminat ;
owl:someValuesFrom ontology:Peminat
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:string ;
owl:onProperty ontology:alias
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:string ;
owl:onProperty ontology:nama
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:onProperty ontology:memiliki_peminat ;
owl:someValuesFrom ontology:Peminat
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:string ;
owl:onProperty ontology:alias
] ;
rdfs:subClassOf [ a owl:Restriction ;
owl:allValuesFrom xsd:string ;
owl:onProperty ontology:nama
] .
ontology:Non_Reguler a ontology:Jalur_Terima , owl:NamedIndividual .
ontology:Pem_Non_2017
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 0 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:Non_Reguler ;
ontology:tahun 2017 .
ontology:Pem_Non_2018
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 0 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:Non_Reguler ;
ontology:tahun 2018 .
ontology:Pem_SAP_2017
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 8 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:SAP ;
ontology:tahun 2017 .
ontology:SAP a ontology:Jalur_Terima , owl:NamedIndividual .
ontology:Pem_SAP_2018
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 7 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:SAP ;
ontology:tahun 2018 .
ontology:Pem_SBM_2017
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 6 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:SBMPTN ;
ontology:tahun 2017 .
ontology:SBMPTN a ontology:Jalur_Terima , owl:NamedIndividual .
ontology:Pem_SBM_2018
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 5 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:SBMPTN ;
ontology:tahun 2018 .
ontology:Pem_SNM_2017
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 4 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:SNMPTN ;
ontology:tahun 2017 .
ontology:SNMPTN a ontology:Jalur_Terima , owl:NamedIndividual .
ontology:Pem_SNM_2018
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 3 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:SNMPTN ;
ontology:tahun 2018 .
ontology:Pem_SPMK_2017
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 2 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:SPMK ;
ontology:tahun 2017 .
ontology:SPMK a ontology:Jalur_Terima , owl:NamedIndividual .
ontology:Pem_SPMK_2018
a ontology:Peminat , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:jumlah 1 ;
ontology:melalui_jalur ontology:SPMK ;
ontology:tahun 2018 .
ontology:TIF a ontology:Prodi , owl:NamedIndividual ;
ontology:memiliki_peminat ontology:Pem_Non_2017 , ontology:Pem_Non_2018 , ontology:Pem_SAP_2017 , ontology:Pem_SAP_2018 , ontology:Pem_SBM_2017 , ontology:Pem_SBM_2018 , ontology:Pem_SNM_2017 , ontology:Pem_SNM_2018 , ontology:Pem_SPMK_2017 , ontology:Pem_SPMK_2018 .
Expected Result :
i want to access (tahun and jumlah)-data property in Peminat based on Jalur_Terima so the data can showed into this
table
right now i can access my table using this query
PREFIX rdf: <http://www.w3.org/1999/02/22-rdf-syntax-ns#>
PREFIX rdfs: <http://www.w3.org/2000/01/rdf-schema#>
PREFIX owl: <http://www.w3.org/2002/07/owl#>
PREFIX xsd: <http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema#>
PREFIX x: <http://www.x.com/ontology/>
SELECT ?tahun ?snm_pem ?sbm_pem ?spmk_pem ?sap_pem ?non_pem
WHERE {
Bind(x:TIF as ?tif)
?tif x:memiliki_peminat ?pem1.
?pem1 x:tahun ?tahun;
x:melalui_jalur x:SNMPTN;
x:jumlah ?snm_pem.
x:TIF x:memiliki_peminat ?pem2.
?pem2 x:tahun ?tahun;
x:melalui_jalur x:SBMPTN;
x:jumlah ?sbm_pem.
x:TIF x:memiliki_peminat ?pem3.
?pem3 x:tahun ?tahun;
x:melalui_jalur x:SPMK;
x:jumlah ?spmk_pem.
x:TIF x:memiliki_peminat ?pem4.
?pem4 x:tahun ?tahun;
x:melalui_jalur x:SAP;
x:jumlah ?sap_pem.
x:TIF x:memiliki_peminat ?pem5.
?pem5 x:tahun ?tahun;
x:melalui_jalur x:Non_Reguler;
x:jumlah ?non_pem.
}
ORDER BY DESC(?tahun)
i'd like to ask,
how to simplify this Query? or is there any other method to access it?
thank you