Good morning, everyone!
I have a pretty simple SELECT/JOIN statement that gets some imported data from a placement test and returns the highest scored attempt a user made, the best score. Users can take this test multiple times, so we just use the best attempt. What if a user makes multiple attempts (say, takes it twice,) and receives the SAME score both times?
My current query ends up returning BOTH of those records, as they're both equal, so MAX() returns both. There are no primary keys setup on this yet--the query I'm using below is the one I hope to add into an INSERT statement for another table, once I only get a SINGLE best attempt per User (StudentID), and set that StudentID as the key. So you see my problem...
I've tried a few DISTINCT or TOP statements in my query but either I'm putting them into the wrong part of the query or they still return two records for a user who had identically scored attempts. Any suggestions?
SELECT p.*
FROM
(SELECT
StudentID, MAX(PlacementResults) AS PlacementResults
FROM AleksMathResults
GROUP BY StudentID)
AS mx
JOIN AleksMathResults p ON mx.StudentID = p.StudentID AND mx.PlacementResults = p.PlacementResults
ORDER BY
StudentID
Sounds like you want row_number():
SELECT amr.*
FROM (SELECT amr.*
ROW_NUMBER() OVER (PARTITION BY StudentID ORDER BY PlacementResults DESC) as seqnum
FROM AleksMathResults amr
) amr
WHERE seqnum = 1;
Related
I am writing a specific sql query that needs to return the position of a particular entry, based on a grouped table.
Background info: I am coding a Golf Club Data Management system using Java and MS Access. In this system, the user is able to store their scores as a new entry into this table. Using this table, I have managed to extract a ranking of the top 3 Golf players, using all their recorded scores (I only used top 3 to preserve screen space).
Select TOP 3 Username, Sum(Points)
FROM Scores
GROUP By Username
ORDER BY Sum(Points) desc
This produces the required result. However, if the current user falls outside of the top 3, I want to be able to tell the user where they currently sit in the complete ranking of all the players. So, I tried to write a query that counts the number of players having a sum of points below the current user. Here is my query:
Select COUNT(*)
From Scores
GROUP BY Username
HAVING Sum(Points) < (Select Sum(Points)
FROM Scores
WHERE Username = 'Golfer210'
GROUP By Username)
This does not produce the expected number 2, but instead does this.
I have tried removing the GROUP BY function but that returns null. The COUNT DISTINCT Function refuses to work as well, and continuously returns a syntax error message, no matter how I word it.
Questions: Is there a way to count the number of entries while using a GROUP BY function? if not, is there an easier, more practical way to select the position of an entry from the grouped table? Or can this only be done in Java, after the ranking has been extracted from the database? I have not been able to find a solution anywhere
You need an additional level of aggregation:
SELECT COUNT(*)
FROM (SELECT COUNT(*)
FROM Scores
GROUP BY Username
HAVING Sum(Points) < (SELECT Sum(Points)
FROM Scores
WHERE Username = 'Golfer210'
)
) as s;
Note: You might want to check if your logic does what you expect when there are ties.
I wrote several SQL queries and executed them against my table. Each individual query worked. I kept adding functionality until I got a really ugly working query. The problem is that I have to manually change a value every time I want to use it. Can you assist in making this query automatic rather than “manual”?
I am working with DB2.
Table below shows customers (cid) from 1 to 3. 'club' is a book seller, and 'qnty' is the number of books the customer bought from each 'club'. The full table has 45 customers.
Image below shows all the table elements for the first 3 users (cid=1 OR cid=2 OR cid=3). The final purpose of all my queries (once combined) is it to find the single 'club' with the largest 'qnty' for each 'cid'. So for 'cid =1' the 'club' is Readers Digest with 'qnty' of 3. For 'cid=2' the 'club' is YRB Gold with 'qnty' of 5. On and on until cid 45 is reached.
To give you a background on what I did here are my queries:
(Query 1-starting point for cid=1)
SELECT * FROM yrb_purchase WHERE cid=1
(Query 2 - find the 'club' with the highest 'qnty' for cid=1)
SELECT *
FROM
(SELECT club,
sum(qnty) AS t_qnty
FROM yrb_purchase
WHERE cid=1
GROUP BY club)results
ORDER BY t_qnty DESC
(Query 3 – combine the record from the above query with it’s cid)
SELECT cid,
temp.club,
temp.t_qnty
FROM yrb_purchase AS p,
(SELECT *
FROM
(SELECT club,
sum(qnty) AS t_qnty
FROM yrb_purchase
WHERE cid=1
GROUP BY club)results
ORDER BY t_qnty DESC FETCH FIRST 1 ROWS ONLY) AS TEMP
WHERE p.cid=1
AND p.club=temp.club
(Query 4) make sure there is only one record for cid=1
SELECT cid,
temp.club,
temp.t_qnty
FROM yrb_purchase AS p,
(SELECT *
FROM
(SELECT club,
sum(qnty) AS t_qnty
FROM yrb_purchase
WHERE cid=1
GROUP BY club)results
ORDER BY t_qnty DESC FETCH FIRST 1 ROWS ONLY) AS TEMP
WHERE p.cid=1
AND p.club=temp.club FETCH FIRST ROWS ONLY
To get the 'club' with the highest 'qnty' for customer 2, I would simply change the text cid=1 to cid=2 in the last query above. My query seems to always produce the correct results. My question is, how do I modify my query to get the results for all 'cid's from 1 to 45 in a single table? How do I get a table with all the cid values along with the club which sold that cid the most books, and how many books were sold within one tablei? Please keep in mind I am hoping you can modify my query as opposed to you providing a better query.
If you decide that my query is way too ugly (I agree with you) and choose to provide another query, please be aware that I just started learning SQL and may not be able to understand your query. You should be aware that I already asked this question: For common elements, how to find the value based on two columns? SQL but I was not able to make the answer work (due to my SQL limitations - not because the answer wasn't good); and in the absence of a working answer I could not reverse engineer it to understand how it works.
Thanks in advance
****************************EDIT #1*******************************************
The results of the answer is:
You could use OLAP/Window Functions to achieve this:
SELECT
cid,
club,
qnty
FROM
(
SELECT
cid,
club,
qnty,
ROW_NUMBER() OVER (PARTITION BY cid order by qnty desc) as cid_club_rank
FROM
(
SELECT
cid,
club,
sum(qnty) as qnty
FROM yrb_purchase
GROUP BY cid, club
) as sub1
) as sub2
WHERE cid_club_rank = 1
The inner most statement (sub1) just grabs a total quantity for each cid/club combination. The second inner most statement (sub2) creates a row_number for each cid/club combination ordering by the quantity (top down). Then the outer most query chooses only records where that row_number() is 1.
I have a table Orders(id_trip, id_order), table Trip(id_hotel, id_bus, id_type_of_trip) and table Hotel(id_hotel, name).
I would like to get name of the most frequent hotel in table Orders.
SELECT hotel.name from Orders
JOIN Trip
on Orders.id_trip = Trip.id_hotel
JOIN hotel
on trip.id_hotel = hotel.id_hotel
FROM (SELECT hotel.name, rank() over (order by cnt desc) rnk
FROM (SELECT hotel.name, count(*) cnt
FROM Orders
GROUP BY hotel.name))
WHERE rnk = 1;
The "most frequently occurring value" in a distribution is a distinct concept in statistics, with a technical name. It's called the MODE of the distribution. And Oracle has the STATS_MODE() function for it. https://docs.oracle.com/cd/B19306_01/server.102/b14200/functions154.htm
For example, using the EMP table in the standard SCOTT schema, select stats_mode(deptno) from scott.emp will return 30 - the number of the department with the most employees. (30 is the department "name" or number, it is NOT the number of employees in that department!)
In your case:
select stats_mode(h.name) from (the rest of your query)
Note: if two or more hotels are tied for "most frequent", then STATS_MODE() will return one of them (non-deterministic). If you need all the tied values, you will need a different solution - a good example is in the documentation (linked above). This is a documented flaw in Oracle's understanding and implementation of the statistical concept.
Use FIRST for a single result:
SELECT MAX(hotel.name) KEEP (DENSE_RANK FIRST ORDER BY cnt DESC)
FROM (
SELECT hotel.name, COUNT(*) cnt
FROM orders
JOIN trip USING (id_trip)
JOIN hotel USING (id_hotel)
GROUP BY hotel.name
) t
Here is one method:
select name
from (select h.name,
row_number() over (order by count(*) desc) as seqnum -- use `rank()` if you want duplicates
from orders o join
trip t
on o.id_trip = t.id_trip join -- this seems like the right join condition
hotels h
on t.id_hotel = h.id_hotel
) oth
where seqnum = 1;
** Getting the most recent statistical mode out of a data sample **
I know it's more than a year, but here's my answer. I came across this question hoping to find a simpler solution than what I know, but alas, nope.
I had a similar situation where I needed to get the mode from a data sample, with the requirement to get the mode of the most recently inserted value if there were multiple modes.
In such a case neither the STATS_MODE nor the LAST aggregate functions would do (as they would tend to return the first mode found, not necessarily the mode with the most recent entries.)
In my case it was easy to use the ROWNUM pseudo-column because the tables in question were performance metric tables that only experienced inserts (not updates)
In this oversimplified example, I'm using ROWNUM - it could easily be changed to a timestamp or sequence field if you have one.
SELECT VALUE
FROM
(SELECT VALUE ,
COUNT( * ) CNT,
MAX( R ) R
FROM
( SELECT ID, ROWNUM R FROM FOO
)
GROUP BY ID
ORDER BY CNT DESC,
R DESC
)
WHERE
(
ROWNUM < 2
);
That is, get the total count and max ROWNUM for each value (I'm assuming the values are discrete. If they aren't, this ain't gonna work.)
Then sort so that the ones with largest counts come first, and for those with the same count, the one with the largest ROWNUM (indicating most recent insertion in my case).
Then skim off the top row.
Your specific data model should have a way to discern the most recent (or the oldest or whatever) rows inserted in your table, and if there are collisions, then there's not much of a way other than using ROWNUM or getting a random sample of size 1.
If this doesn't work for your specific case, you'll have to create your own custom aggregator.
Now, if you don't care which mode Oracle is going to pick (your bizness case just requires a mode and that's it, then STATS_MODE will do fine.
I shall link my database down below.
I have a query called 'TestMonday1' and what this does is return the student with the fewest 'NoOfFrees' and insert the result of the query into the lesson table. Running the query should help explain what i mean. The problem im having is my SQL code has 'SELECT TOP 1' yet if the query returns two students who have the same number of frees it returns both these records. Wit this being a timetable planner, it should only ever return one result, i shall also put the code below,
Many thanks
Code:
INSERT INTO Lesson ( StudentID, LessonStart, LessonEnd, DayOfWeek )
SELECT TOP 1 Availability.StudentID, Availability.StartTime,
Availability.EndTime, Availability.DayOfWeek
FROM Availability
WHERE
Availability.StartTime='16:00:00' AND
Availability.EndTime='18:00:00' AND
Availability.DayOfWeek='Monday' AND
LessonTaken IS NULL
ORDER BY
Availability.NoOfFrees;
This happens because Access returns all records in case of ties in ORDER BY (all records returned have the same values of fields used in ORDER BY).
You can add another field to ORDER BY to make sure there's no ties. StudentID looks like a good candidate (though I don't know your schema, replace with something else if it suits better):
ORDER BY
Availability.NoOfFrees, Availability.StudentID;
Say that I have some SELECT statement:
SELECT id, name FROM people
ORDER BY name ASC;
I have a few million rows in the people table and the ORDER BY clause can be much more complex than what I have shown here (possibly operating on a dozen columns).
I retrieve only a small subset of the rows (say rows 1..11) in order to display them in the UI. Now, I would like to solve following problems:
Find the number of a row with a given id.
Display the 5 items before and the 5 items after a row with a given id.
Problem 2 is easy to solve once I have solved problem 1, as I can then use something like this if I know that the item I was looking for has row number 1000 in the sorted result set (this is the Firebird SQL dialect):
SELECT id, name FROM people
ORDER BY name ASC
ROWS 995 TO 1005;
I also know that I can find the rank of a row by counting all of the rows which come before the one I am looking for, but this can lead to very long WHERE clauses with tons of OR and AND in the condition. And I have to do this repeatedly. With my test data, this takes hundreds of milliseconds, even when using properly indexed columns, which is way too slow.
Is there some means of achieving this by using some SQL:2003 features (such as row_number supported in Firebird 3.0)? I am by no way an SQL guru and I need some pointers here. Could I create a cached view where the result would include a rank/dense rank/row index?
Firebird appears to support window functions (called analytic functions in Oracle). So you can do the following:
To find the "row" number of a a row with a given id:
select id, row_number() over (partition by NULL order by name, id)
from t
where id = <id>
This assumes the id's are unique.
To solve the second problem:
select t.*
from (select id, row_number() over (partition by NULL order by name, id) as rownum
from t
) t join
(select id, row_number() over (partition by NULL order by name, id) as rownum
from t
where id = <id>
) tid
on t.rownum between tid.rownum - 5 and tid.rownum + 5
I might suggest something else, though, if you can modify the table structure. Most databases offer the ability to add an auto-increment column when a row is inserted. If your records are never deleted, this can server as your counter, simplifying your queries.