I have some data in an Oracle table which is stored in an XML-format string (column response in table WS_LOG).
I would like to extract data from each different node below <MedicalProcedureOutput>, but I'm having some difficulties in getting to each of the nodes. Can you spot what I'm doing wrong?
Here's what I'm trying (here trying to retrieve the value for the icpcID tag):
SELECT a.id,
t1.icpcID FROM
GH.WS_LOG a,
xmltable(
xmlnamespaces(
'http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/' as "soap",
'http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema' as "xsd",
'http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance' as "xsi"),
'/soap:Envelope/soap:Body/createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResponse/createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResult/proceduresList/MedicalProcedureOutput' passing xmltype(a.response) columns
icpcID varchar2(50) path 'ipcdId') t1
And here's some example data
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<soap:Envelope xmlns:soap="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/" xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
<soap:Body>
<createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResponse xmlns="urn:bcpcorp.net/ws/bsgFacets/FacetsBillingService">
<createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResult>
<status>0</status>
<outputMessage />
<statusElement />
<claimID>18E002021300</claimID>
<claimStatus>01</claimStatus>
<claimStatusReason>AGFP</claimStatusReason>
<totalChargeValue>35.0000</totalChargeValue>
<totalPayableValue>0.0000</totalPayableValue>
<paitentPaidvalue>17.5</paitentPaidvalue>
<totalDebitAmount>0</totalDebitAmount>
<proceduresList>
<MedicalProcedureOutput>
<ipcdId>011801</ipcdId>
<otherdisallowedAmountResponsibility>N</otherdisallowedAmountResponsibility>
</MedicalProcedureOutput>
</proceduresList>
</createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResult>
</createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResponse>
</soap:Body>
</soap:Envelope>
I would expect to be getting the value '011801'. Please note that multiple <MedicalProcedureOutput> nodes may occur, and they would be organized as follows:
<MedicalProcedureOutput>
<ipcdId>725013</ipcdId>
<otherdisallowedAmountResponsibility>N</otherdisallowedAmountResponsibility>
</MedicalProcedureOutput>
<MedicalProcedureOutput>
<ipcdId>725105</ipcdId>
<otherdisallowedAmountResponsibility>N</otherdisallowedAmountResponsibility>
</MedicalProcedureOutput>
You need to declare a default namespace for everything from within the body, since createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResponse has its own xmlns unnamed (therefore default) declaration which applies from that node onwards; so:
SELECT a.id,
t1.icpcID FROM
GH.WS_LOG a,
xmltable(
xmlnamespaces(
default 'urn:bcpcorp.net/ws/bsgFacets/FacetsBillingService',
'http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/' as "soap",
'http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema' as "xsd",
'http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance' as "xsi"
),
'/soap:Envelope/soap:Body/createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResponse/createBillingSubmissionForAFEBSGResult/proceduresList/MedicalProcedureOutput' passing xmltype(a.response) columns
icpcID varchar2(50) path 'ipcdId') t1
/
ID ICPCID
---------- --------------------------------------------------
1 011801
or with multiple nodes as you showed later int he question this will return:
ID ICPCID
---------- --------------------------------------------------
2 725013
2 725105
db<>fiddle
You should take a look into to solve it with the EXTRACTVALUE function, here You can find some information about it.
Related
One of our requirements is to get the value of all the child nodes of a given specific XML node.
I have got a solution for this using Microsoft SQL Server but I need the same in Oracle. Please see the below query.
Note: incase if there is more than one child node, the result should be the concatenation of all the individual child nodes'value.
select
REPLACE(Properties, 'utf-8', 'utf-16'),
CAST(REPLACE(Col1, 'utf-8', 'utf-16') as XML).value('(//*[local-name() = sql:variable("#var2")])[1]', 'varchar(200)')
from A
Following is a sample data/row from Col1:
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><ConstantInputProperties xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"><Value xsi:type="xsd:int">0</Value></ConstantInputProperties>
here A is the table and Col1 is one of the columns of table A.
I tried to convert below Solution but it gives me the XML instead of values.
SELECT col1,
EXTRACT(XMLTYPE(col1), '(/*[local-name()="ConstantInputProperties"][1])')
FROM A
Example:
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><ConstantInputProperties xmlns:xsd="w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"><Value xsi:type="ArrayOfInt"><int>0</int><int>1</int></Value></ConstantInputProperties>
Expected Output 01
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><ConstantInputProperties xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"><Value xsi:type="ArrayOfBoolean"><boolean>true</boolean><boolean>true</boolean><boolean>true</boolean><boolean>true</boolean><boolean>true</boolean></Value></ConstantInputProperties>
Expected Output truetruetruetruetrue
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><ConstantInputProperties xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"><Value xsi:type="ArrayOfDecimal"><decimal>1.0000000000</decimal></Value></ConstantInputProperties>
Expected Output 1.0000000000
You could manipulate the XML inside an XPath with FLWOR syntax, but you could also use XMLTable to extract all the values; or rather, two XMLTables, one for a singleton element type and a second optional one for array expansion; get all the values as strings; and aggregate the results together:
select a.id,
listagg(coalesce(x1.value, x2.value), ' ')
within group (order by coalesce(x1.n, x2.n)) as result
from a
cross apply xmltable (
'(/*[local-name()=$var1][1])'
passing xmltype(col1), 'ConstantInputProperties' as "var1"
columns
n for ordinality,
value varchar2(30) path 'Value[#xsi:type="xsd:int"]',
array xmltype path 'Value[fn:starts-with(#xsi:type, "ArrayOf")]'
) x1
outer apply xmltable (
'Value/*'
passing array
columns
n for ordinality,
value varchar2(30) path '.'
) x2
group by a.id;
ID | RESULT
-: | :-----------------------
1 | 0
2 | 0 1
3 | true true true true true
4 | 1.0000000000
db<>fiddle
The n for ordinality just gives a numeric value that lets you keep the original sub-element order when aggregating (so you get 0 1 and not 1 0), If you don't want a spaces added to to the aggregated value then just change the second listagg argument from ' ' to null, though then you can't sell the difference between a singleton 10 and a pair of values with 1 and 0, so that doesn't seem very useful - not that an aggregated value seems that useful anyway really.
You could split into multiple sub-XMLTables, but that's probably not going to gain you anything here; db<>fiddle for info though.
can you suggest how to pass the ConstantInputProperties value as an argument and use it as a variable in function input in this case EXTRACT(XMLTYPE(col1), '(/[local-name()="ConstantInputProperties"]//text())')
The extract() function is deprecated. Use XMLQuery instead; for example:
select xmlquery(
'(/*[local-name()=$var1][1])/Value/text()'
passing xmltype(col1), 'ConstantInputProperties' as "var1"
returning content)
from a
Few examples:
with a as (
select q'[<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><ConstantInputProperties xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"><Value xsi:type="xsd:int">0</Value></ConstantInputProperties>
]' col1 from dual
)
select
x.*
from
a,
xmltable(
'//*[local-name()="ConstantInputProperties"][1]'
passing xmltype(a.col1)
columns
res xmltype path '.'
) x;
--Result:
RES
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
<ConstantInputProperties xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"><Value xsi:type="xsd:int">0</Value></ConstantInputProperties>
with a as (
select q'[<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?><ConstantInputProperties xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance"><Value xsi:type="xsd:int">0</Value></ConstantInputProperties>
]' col1 from dual
)
select
x.*
from
a,
xmltable(
'//*[local-name()="ConstantInputProperties"]/*/text()'
passing xmltype(a.col1)
columns
res xmltype path '.'
) x;
--Result:
RES
--------------------------------------------------------------
<Value xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xsi:type="xsd:int">0</Value>
I am trying to extract the Values based on Name via Oracle SQL query from the XML returned by a SOAP web service response, however it's resulting in errors. I could extract AdName, AdCat using this XMLTYPE method, but not the ones that's embedded further inside Results and AdSettings attributes. I must be wrong with the syntax I am using. Any help is appreciated.
SQL Query with XML Response:
WITH xmltest (id, data_xml) AS (
SELECT 1, XMLTYPE('<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<soap:Envelope xmlns:soap="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/" xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema">
<soap:Header>
<ResponseHeader xmlns="https://www.google.com/apis/ads/v202005">
<requestId>123456</requestId>
</ResponseHeader>
</soap:Header>
<soap:Body>
<getAdsResponse xmlns="https://www.google.com/apis/ads/v202005">
<getAdsResult>
<ResultReceived>1</ResultReceived>
<AdName>Target Comm. Systems</AdName>
<AdCat>COMMERCIAL</AdCat>
<SessionID>654321</SessionID>
<Results>
<Result><Name>ADId</Name><Value>2372</Value></Result>
<Result><Name>AdStatus</Name><Value>ACTIVE</Value></Result>
<Result><Name>targetWindow</Name><Value>TOP</Value></Result>
</Results>
<AdSettings>
<Setting><Name>fontFamily</Name><Value>DEFAULT</Value></Setting>
<Setting><Name>fontSize</Name><Value>9</Value></Setting>
<Setting><Name>adSenseEnabled</Name><Value>TRUE</Value></Setting>
<Setting><Name>adType</Name><Value>TEXT_AND_IMAGE</Value></Setting>
</AdSettings>
</getAdsResult>
</getAdsResponse>
</soap:Body>
</soap:Envelope>') FROM SYS.DUAL
)
SELECT x.Ad_Name,
x.Ad_Category,
x.Ad_ID,
x.Ad_Status,
x.AdSense_Enabled,
x.Ad_Type
FROM xmltest d,
XMLTABLE ( XMLNAMESPACES ( 'http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/' AS "soap",
'https://www.google.com/apis/ads/v202005' AS "AdsNs2"
),
'/soap:Envelope/soap:Body/AdsNs2:getAdsResponse/AdsNs2:getAdsResult'
PASSING d.data_xml
COLUMNS Ad_Name VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2:AdName',
Ad_Category VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2:AdCat',
Ad_ID VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2/Results:Result[Name="ADId"]/Value',
Ad_Status VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2/Results:Result[Name="AdStatus"]/Value',
AdSense_Enabled VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2/Results:Result[Name="adSenseEnabled"]/Value',
Ad_Type VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2/Results:Result[Name="adType"]/Value'
) x;
Error:
ORA-19112: error raised during evaluation:
XVM-01081: [XPST0081] Invalid prefix
1 declare namespace soap="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/";declare
- ^
19112. 00000 - "error raised during evaluation: %s"
*Cause: The error function was called during evaluation of the XQuery expression.
*Action: Check the detailed error message for the possible causes.
Error at Line: 39 Column: 10
The last four columns XPath expressions were completely off. Here is how to do it correctly.
SQL
WITH xmltest (id, data_xml) AS (
SELECT 1, XMLTYPE('<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-8"?>
<soap:Envelope xmlns:soap="http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/" xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema">
<soap:Header>
<ResponseHeader xmlns="https://www.google.com/apis/ads/v202005">
<requestId>123456</requestId>
</ResponseHeader>
</soap:Header>
<soap:Body>
<getAdsResponse xmlns="https://www.google.com/apis/ads/v202005">
<getAdsResult>
<ResultReceived>1</ResultReceived>
<AdName>Target Comm. Systems</AdName>
<AdCat>COMMERCIAL</AdCat>
<SessionID>654321</SessionID>
<Results>
<Result><Name>ADId</Name><Value>2372</Value></Result>
<Result><Name>AdStatus</Name><Value>ACTIVE</Value></Result>
<Result><Name>targetWindow</Name><Value>TOP</Value></Result>
</Results>
<AdSettings>
<Setting><Name>fontFamily</Name><Value>DEFAULT</Value></Setting>
<Setting><Name>fontSize</Name><Value>9</Value></Setting>
<Setting><Name>adSenseEnabled</Name><Value>TRUE</Value></Setting>
<Setting><Name>adType</Name><Value>TEXT_AND_IMAGE</Value></Setting>
</AdSettings>
</getAdsResult>
</getAdsResponse>
</soap:Body>
</soap:Envelope>') FROM SYS.DUAL
)
SELECT x.Ad_Name,
x.Ad_Category,
x.Ad_ID,
x.Ad_Status,
x.AdSense_Enabled,
x.Ad_Type
FROM xmltest d,
XMLTABLE ( XMLNAMESPACES ( 'http://schemas.xmlsoap.org/soap/envelope/' AS "soap",
'https://www.google.com/apis/ads/v202005' AS "AdsNs2"
),
'/soap:Envelope/soap:Body/AdsNs2:getAdsResponse/AdsNs2:getAdsResult'
PASSING d.data_xml
COLUMNS Ad_Name VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2:AdName',
Ad_Category VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2:AdCat',
Ad_ID VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2:Results/AdsNs2:Result[AdsNs2:Name="ADId"]/AdsNs2:Value',
Ad_Status VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2:Results/AdsNs2:Result[AdsNs2:Name="AdStatus"]/AdsNs2:Value',
AdSense_Enabled VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2:AdSettings/AdsNs2:Setting[AdsNs2:Name="adSenseEnabled"]/AdsNs2:Value',
Ad_Type VARCHAR2(50) PATH 'AdsNs2:AdSettings/AdsNs2:Setting[AdsNs2:Name="adType"]/AdsNs2:Value'
) x;
My XML Looks like below
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1" standalone="no"?>
<wfm:Statement xmlns:wfm="http://example.org/sample/xsd/sampleStatement/2013/05" xmlns:wfmMerchant="http://www.eds.com/sample/xsd/wfmMerchant/2012/03"
xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
<wfm:StatementParameters>
<wfmMerchant:HierarchyCd>012-12-002-107-050</wfmMerchant:HierarchyCd>
</wfm:StatementParameters>
<StatementAmount>27.140</StatementAmount>
</wfm:Statement>
I am trying to get the value of StatementAmount tag using Oracle query like below
select MS.MERCHANT,MS.CHAIN_HIERARCHY_CD,MS.CYCLE_DATE, X.StatementAmount
FROM CHAIN_STATMNT_HIST_XML MS
CROSS JOIN XMLTABLE(XMLNAMESPACES('http://example.org/sample/xsd/sampleStatement/2013/05' AS "wfm", 'http://www.eds.com/sample/xsd/wfmMerchant/2012/03' as wfmmerchant
default 'http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance')
,'/wfm:Statement/StatementAmount' passing xmltype(MS.XML_REPORT)
columns StatementAmount varchar(18) path '.')X
But, I am always getting NULL. I can able to successfully retrieve Hierarchy value from the XML which has namespace. But StatementAmount tag doesn't have any namespace and I have trouble retrieving it.
Can someone help with this issue ?
Your default namespace declaration seems to be causing the problem; without that (and ignoring wfmMerchant):
-- CTE for sample data
with CHAIN_STATMNT_HIST_XML (merchant, chain_hierarchy_cd, cycle_date, XML_REPORT) as (
select 1, 2, sysdate, '<?xml version="1.0" encoding="ISO-8859-1" standalone="no"?>
<wfm:Statement xmlns:wfm="http://example.org/sample/xsd/sampleStatement/2013/05" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance">
<wfm:StatementParameters>
<!-- excluding this as namespace not provided -->
<!-- <wfmMerchant:HierarchyCd>012-12-002-107-050</wfmMerchant:HierarchyCd> -->
</wfm:StatementParameters>
<StatementAmount>27.140</StatementAmount>
</wfm:Statement>' from dual
)
-- actual query
select MS.MERCHANT,MS.CHAIN_HIERARCHY_CD,MS.CYCLE_DATE, X.StatementAmount
FROM CHAIN_STATMNT_HIST_XML MS
CROSS JOIN XMLTABLE(
XMLNAMESPACES('http://example.org/sample/xsd/sampleStatement/2013/05' AS "wfm"),
'/wfm:Statement/StatementAmount' passing xmltype(MS.XML_REPORT)
columns StatementAmount varchar(18) path '.'
) X
/
MERCHANT CHAIN_HIERARCHY_CD CYCLE_DATE STATEMENTAMOUNT
---------- ------------------ ---------- ------------------
1 2 2018-09-04 27.140
I'm not sure why you would use varchar2(18) as the datatype rather than number; and if there is only one statement amount per statement you could do:
select MS.MERCHANT,MS.CHAIN_HIERARCHY_CD,MS.CYCLE_DATE, X.StatementAmount
FROM CHAIN_STATMNT_HIST_XML MS
CROSS JOIN XMLTABLE(
XMLNAMESPACES('http://example.org/sample/xsd/sampleStatement/2013/05' AS "wfm"),
'/wfm:Statement' passing xmltype(MS.XML_REPORT)
columns StatementAmount number path 'StatementAmount'
) X
I am attempting to extract information from XML stored in a CLOB column. I've searched the forums and thus far have been unable to get the data to pull as needed. I have a basic understanding of SQL but this is beyond me.
The XML is similar to the following:
<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<Response>
<Header>
<OrderNum value="12354321"/>
<ExtractDate value="11-30-2012"/>
<RType value="Status"/>
<Company value="Company"/>
</Header>
<Body>
<Status>
<Order>
<ActivityType value="ValidateRequest"/>
<EndUser>
<Name value="Schmo, Joe"/>
<Address>
<SANO value="12345"/>
<SASN value="Mickey Mouse"/>
<SATH value="Lane"/>
<SASS value="N"/>
<City value="Orlando"/>
<State value="FL"/>
<Zip value="34786"/>
<Number value="5550000"/>
</Address>
</EndUser>
<COS value="1"/>
<TOS value="3"/>
<MainNumber value="5550000"/>
</Order>
<ErrorCode value="400"/>
<ErrorMessage value="RECEIVED"/>
</Status>
</Body>
</Response>
I want to get the values under "Address".
I've tried the following but it returns "NULL".
SELECT EXTRACTVALUE(XMLTYPE(RESPONSE_CLOB),'/Response/Body/Status/Order/EndUser/Address/SANO') AS SANO
FROM RESPONSE_TABLE
WHERE ROWNUM < 2
I am trying to get it so I can pull the "12345" assigned as "value" in "SANO" (ultimately getting the value for other fields, but want to at least get the one working first).
You're currently retrieving the text value of the node, but 12345 is the value attribute of the element rather than its text content. So you would need to use the #attribute syntax, i.e.:
SELECT EXTRACTVALUE(XMLTYPE(RESPONSE_CLOB),'/Response/Body/Status/Order/EndUser/Address/SANO/#value') AS SANO
FROM RESPONSE_TABLE
WHERE ROWNUM < 2;
SANO
--------------------
12345
But extractvalue is deprecated; assuming you're on a recent version of Oracle it would be better to use an XMLQuery:
SELECT XMLQUERY(
'/Response/Body/Status/Order/EndUser/Address/SANO/#value'
PASSING XMLTYPE(RESPONSE_CLOB)
RETURNING CONTENT
) AS SANO
FROM RESPONSE_TABLE
WHERE ROWNUM < 2;
You may find it even easier to use an XMLTable - necessary if an XML document has multiple Address nodes, but even with just one pulling the values out as columns is less repetitive, and it makes it easier to retrieve suitable data types:
select x.*
from response_table rt
cross join xmltable(
'/Response/Body/Status/Order/EndUser/Address'
passing xmltype(rt.response_clob)
columns sano number path 'SANO/#value',
sasn varchar2(30) path 'SASN/#value',
sath varchar2(10) path 'SATH/#value'
-- etc.
) x
where rownum < 2;
SANO SASN SATH
-------------------- ------------------------------ ----------
12345 Mickey Mouse Lane
Read more about using these functions to query XML data.
I'm having difficulties extracting the value from certain nodes in an XML structure using XMLTABLE. Below query works perfectly when you remove the xmlns="" attribute from the SubListItem nodes. And as you can see, the XML already has a default namespace. I honestly have no clue how I can deal with this "blanking out" of the namespace on certain nodes like this.
For further clarification, the creation of this XML is not within my control and is provided by a third-party. I've also changed the names of the nodes and the content from the delivered files while preserving the structure of the XML.
SELECT f.airline, f.flightnumber, fl.gate
FROM xmltable(
xmlnamespaces(
default 'http://some/name.space',
'http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema' as "xsd",
'http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance' as "xsi"
),
'Body/Flight'
passing xmltype(
'<?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-16"?>
<Body xmlns:xsd="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema" xmlns:xsi="http://www.w3.org/2001/XMLSchema-instance" xmlns="http://some/name.space">
<Sender>
<System>ConnectionManagement</System>
</Sender>
<Flight>
<Airline>ABC</Airline>
<Number>1234</Number>
<SubList>
<SubListItem xmlns="">
<Gate>X</Gate>
</SubListItem>
<SubListItem xmlns="">
<Gate>Y</Gate>
</SubListItem>
<SubListItem xmlns="">
<Gate>Z</Gate>
</SubListItem>
</SubList>
</Flight>
</Body>'
)
columns airline varchar2(100) path 'Airline'
, flightNumber VARCHAR2(5) path 'Number'
, subList XMLTYPE path 'SubList'
) f
, xmltable (
xmlnamespaces( default 'http://some/name.space'),
'/SubList/SubListItem'
passing f.subList
columns gate varchar2(5) path 'Gate'
) fl
;
How can I target the Gate node when the XML looks like this?
Leave the default namespace alone in the second XMLTable, and specify a named namespace for the path you do have:
...
, xmltable (
xmlnamespaces( 'http://some/name.space' as "ns"),
'/ns:SubList/SubListItem'
passing f.subList
columns gate varchar2(5) path 'Gate'
) fl
;
AIRLINE FLIGH GATE
---------- ----- -----
ABC 1234 X
ABC 1234 Y
ABC 1234 Z
The SubList still has to match that, but as the child nodes don't the default is incorrect the way you have it. If you remove the xmlns="" as you mentioned in the question then that inherits the namespace from its parent, so your default works. With that override to no-namespace you can't use a default.