SQL Server 2005: column cannot be persisted because is non-deterministic [duplicate] - sql

Question

I have the following user-defined function:
create function [dbo].[FullNameLastFirst]
(
#IsPerson bit,
#LastName nvarchar(100),
#FirstName nvarchar(100)
)
returns nvarchar(201)
as
begin
declare #Result nvarchar(201)
set #Result = (case when #IsPerson = 0 then #LastName else case when #FirstName = '' then #LastName else (#LastName + ' ' + #FirstName) end end)
return #Result
end
I can't create an Index on a computed column using this function cause it's not deterministic.
Someone could explain why is it not deterministic and eventually how to modify to make it deterministic?
Thanks

Answer 1

You just need to create it with schemabinding.
SQL Server will then verify whether or not it meets the criteria to be considered as deterministic (which it does as it doesn't access any external tables or use non deterministic functions such as getdate()).
You can verify that it worked with
SELECT OBJECTPROPERTY(OBJECT_ID('[dbo].[FullNameLastFirst]'), 'IsDeterministic')
Adding the schemabinding option to your original code works fine but a slightly simpler version would be.
CREATE FUNCTION [dbo].[FullNameLastFirst] (#IsPerson BIT,
#LastName NVARCHAR(100),
#FirstName NVARCHAR(100))
RETURNS NVARCHAR(201)
WITH SCHEMABINDING
AS
BEGIN
RETURN CASE
WHEN #IsPerson = 0
OR #FirstName = '' THEN #LastName
ELSE #LastName + ' ' + #FirstName
END
END

Answer 2

You need to declare the User Defined Function WITH SCHEMABINDING to appease the 'deterministic' requirement of an index on the computed column.
A function declared WITH SCHEMABINDING will retain additional knowledge about the object dependencies used in the function (e.g. columns in the table), and will prevent any changes to these columns, unless the function itself is dropped beforehand.
Deterministic functions can also assist Sql Server in optimizing its execution plans, most notably the Halloween Protection problem.
Here's an example of creating an index on a computed column using a schema bound function:
create function [dbo].[FullNameLastFirst]
(
#IsPerson bit,
#LastName nvarchar(100),
#FirstName nvarchar(100)
)
returns nvarchar(201)
with schemabinding
as
begin
declare #Result nvarchar(201)
set #Result = (case when #IsPerson = 0 then #LastName
else case when #FirstName = '' then #LastName
else (#LastName + ' ' + #FirstName) end end)
return #Result
end
create table Person
(
isperson bit,
lastname nvarchar(100),
firstname nvarchar(100),
fullname as [dbo].[FullNameLastFirst] (isperson, lastname, firstname)
)
go
insert into person(isperson, lastname, firstname) values (1,'Firstname', 'Surname')
go
create index ix1_person on person(fullname)
go
select fullname from Person with (index=ix1_person) where fullname = 'Firstname Surname'
go