Joining Two Queries onto a Shared Table - sql

Question

I have been struggling with the concept of combining results of two queries together via a join on a common table and I was hoping I could gain some assistance. The following is a rough guide to the tables:
dbo.Asset (not returned in the SELECT statement, used for joins only)
- dbo.Asset.AssetID
- dbo.Asset.CatalogueID
dbo.WorkOrder
- WorkOrderID
- AssetID
- WorkOrderNumber
dbo.WorkOrderSpare
- WorkOrderID
- WorkOrderSpareID
- WorkOrderSpareDescription
- ActualQuantity
- CreatedDateTime
dbo.Catalogue
- CatalogueID (PK)
- CatalogueNumber
- CatalogueDescription
- CatalogueGroupID
dbo.CatalogueGroup
- CatalogueGroupID
- CatalogueGroupNumber
First Query:
SELECT CatalogueGroup.CatalogueGroupName,
Catalogue.CatalogueNumber,
Catalogue.CatalogueDescription,
Catalogue.CatalogueID,
Asset.IsActive
FROM CatalogueGroup
INNER JOIN Catalogue
ON CatalogueGroup.CatalogueGroupID = Catalogue.CatalogueGroupID
INNER JOIN Asset
ON Catalogue.CatalogueID = Asset.CatalogueID
Second Query:
SELECT WorkOrder.WorkOrderNumber,
WorkOrderSpare.WorkOrderSpareDescription,
WorkOrderSpare.ActualQuantity,
WorkOrderSpare.CreatedDateTime
FROM WorkOrder
INNER JOIN WorkOrderSpare
ON WorkOrder.WorkOrderID = WorkOrderSpare.WorkOrderID
Now I can do the above easily enough in Access (WYSIWYG) by joining Asset/Catalogue/CatalogueGroup together and then joining Asset.AssetID onto WorkOrder.AssetID. I can't seem to get anything similar to work via raw code, I think I have my logic correct for the joins (INNER JOIN on the results of both) but then I am new to this.
Any assistance would be greatly appreciated, any pointers on where I can read further into problems like this would be great.
EDIT: This is what I was trying to use to no avail, I should also mention I am trying to do this in ms-sql, not Access (trying to move away from drag and drop):
SELECT CatalogueGroup.CatalogueGroupName,
Catalogue.CatalogueNumber,
Catalogue.CatalogueDescription,
Catalogue.CatalogueID,
Asset.IsActive,
WorkOrderSpare.WorkOrderSpareDescription,
WorkOrderSpare.ActualQuantity,
WorkOrderSpare.CreatedDateTime,
WorkOrder.WorkOrderNumber
FROM (((CatalogueGroup
INNER JOIN Catalogue
ON CatalogueGroup.CatalogueGroupID = Catalogue.CatalogueGroupID)
INNER JOIN Asset ON Catalogue.CatalogueID = Asset.CatalogueID)
INNER JOIN WorkOrderSpare
ON WorkOrder.WorkOrderID = WorkOrderSpare.WorkOrderID)
INNER JOIN WorkOrder ON Asset.AssetID = WorkOrder.AssetID

Answer 1

Think I see the issue. Assuming that the joins themselves are correct (ie your columns do relate to each other), the order of your joins is a little off - when you join WorkOrder to WorkOrderSpare, neither of those two tables relate back to any table you've identified up until that point in the query. Think of it as joining two tables separately from the chain of joins you have going so far - it's almost like doing two separate join queries. If you switch the last two it should work, that way WorkOrder will join to Asset (which you've already defined) and then you can join WorkOrderSpare to WorkOrder. I've also taken the liberty of removing parentheses on the joins, that's an Access thing.
SELECT CatalogueGroup.CatalogueGroupName,
Catalogue.CatalogueNumber,
Catalogue.CatalogueDescription,
Catalogue.CatalogueID,
Asset.IsActive,
WorkOrderSpare.WorkOrderSpareDescription,
WorkOrderSpare.ActualQuantity,
WorkOrderSpare.CreatedDateTime,
WorkOrder.WorkOrderNumber
FROM CatalogueGroup
INNER JOIN Catalogue ON CatalogueGroup.CatalogueGroupID = Catalogue.CatalogueGroupID
INNER JOIN Asset ON Catalogue.CatalogueID = Asset.CatalogueID
INNER JOIN WorkOrder ON Asset.AssetID = WorkOrder.AssetID
INNER JOIN WorkOrderSpare ON WorkOrder.WorkOrderID = WorkOrderSpare.WorkOrderID

Answer 2

I think you were close. As a slightly different approach to joining, try this:
SELECT CatalogueGroup.CatalogueGroupName,
Catalogue.CatalogueNumber,
Catalogue.CatalogueDescription,
Catalogue.CatalogueID,
Asset.IsActive,
WorkOrderSpare.WorkOrderSpareDescription,
WorkOrderSpare.ActualQuantity,
WorkOrderSpare.CreatedDateTime,
WorkOrder.WorkOrderNumber
FROM
CatalogueGroup, Catalogue, Asset, WorkOrder, WorkOrderSpare
WHERE CatalogueGroup.CatalogueGroupID = Catalogue.CatalogueGroupID
and Catalogue.CatalogueID = Asset.CatalogueID
and Asset.AssetID = WorkOrder.AssetID
and WorkOrder.WorkOrderID = WorkOrderSpare.WorkOrderID
It looks like it should work, but not having data, hard to know if simple joins all the way through is what you want. (It's a matter of personal preference whether to use the and clauses rather than the inner join syntax. While on style preferences, I like table aliases if supported, so FROM CatalogueGroup cg for example, so that you can refer to cg.CatalogueGroupID etc, rather than writing out the full table name every time.)

Answer 3

Ok. so the error that you noted in a comment
The multi-part identifier "WorkOrder.WorkOrderID" could not be bound
is usually when you have an alias for a table and instead of using alias in JOIN you use the table name or when you are using the wrong column name or table name.
Ideally in SQL server your query should look like this
SELECT
cg.CatalogueGroupName,
c.CatalogueNumber,
c.CatalogueDescription,
c.CatalogueID,
A.IsActive,
Wo.WorkOrderNumber,
WoS.WorkOrderSpareDescription,
WoS.ActualQuantity,
WoS.CreatedDateTime
FROM CatalogueGroup cg
INNER JOIN Catalogue c ON cg.CatalogueGroupID = c.CatalogueGroupID
INNER JOIN Asset A ON c.CatalogueID = A.CatalogueID
INNER JOIN WorkOrder Wo ON Wo.AssetID= A.AssetID
INNER JOIN WorkOrderSpare WoS ON Wo.WorkOrderID = WoS.WorkOrderID