Excel VBA Custom Function Remove Words Appearing in One String From Another String - vba

Question

I am trying to remove words appearing in one string from a different string using a custom function. For instance:
A1:
the was why blue hat
A2:
the stranger wanted to know why his blue hat was turning orange
The ideal outcome in this example would be:
A3:
stranger wanted to know his turning orange
I need to have the cells in reference open to change so that they can be used in different situations.
The function will be used in a cell as:
=WORDREMOVE("cell with words needing remove", "cell with list of words being removed")
I have a list of 20,000 rows and have managed to find a custom function that can remove duplicate words (below) and thought there may be a way to manipulate it to accomplish this task.
Function REMOVEDUPEWORDS(txt As String, Optional delim As String = " ") As String
Dim x
'Updateby20140924
With CreateObject("Scripting.Dictionary")
.CompareMode = vbTextCompare
For Each x In Split(txt, delim)
If Trim(x) <> "" And Not .exists(Trim(x)) Then .Add Trim(x), Nothing
Next
If .Count > 0 Then REMOVEDUPEWORDS = Join(.keys, delim)
End With
End Function

Answer 1

If you can guarantee that your words in both strings will be separated by spaces (no comma, ellipses, etc), you could just Split() both strings then Filter() out the words:
Function WORDREMOVE(ByVal strText As String, strRemove As String) As String
Dim a, w
a = Split(strText) ' Start with all words in an array
For Each w In Split(strRemove)
a = Filter(a, w, False, vbTextCompare) ' Remove every word found
Next
WORDREMOVE = Join(a, " ") ' Recreate the string
End Function

Answer 2

You can also do this using Regular Expressions in VBA. The version below is case insensitive and assumes all words are separated only by space. If there is other punctuation, more examples would aid in crafting an appropriate solution:
Option Explicit
Function WordRemove(Str As String, RemoveWords As String) As String
Dim RE As Object
Set RE = CreateObject("vbscript.regexp")
With RE
.ignorecase = True
.Global = True
.Pattern = "(?:" & Join(Split(WorksheetFunction.Trim(RemoveWords)), "|") & ")\s*"
WordRemove = .Replace(Str, "")
End With
End Function

Answer 3

My example is certainly not the best code, but it should work
Function WORDREMOVE(FirstCell As String, SecondCell As String)
Dim FirstArgument As Variant, SecondArgument As Variant
Dim FirstArgumentCounter As Integer, SecondArgumentCounter As Integer
Dim Checker As Boolean
WORDREMOVE = ""
FirstArgument = Split(FirstCell, " ")
SecondArgument = Split(SecondCell, " ")
For SecondArgumentCounter = 0 To UBound(SecondArgument)
Checker = False
For FirstArgumentCounter = 0 To UBound(FirstArgument)
If SecondArgument(SecondArgumentCounter) = FirstArgument(FirstArgumentCounter) Then
Checker = True
End If
Next FirstArgumentCounter
If Checker = False Then WORDREMOVE = WORDREMOVE & SecondArgument(SecondArgumentCounter) & " "
Next SecondArgumentCounter
WORDREMOVE = Left(WORDREMOVE, Len(WORDREMOVE) - 1)
End Function