I was wondering, how can I authenticate requests to FireBase?
I have created new firebase account, marked Enable Email & Password Authentication, created a user with e-mail/password and using { ".read": "auth != null" } in security rules for read access.
Using PostMan plugin for chrome, selected basic auth, entered e-mail/password, GET to https://crackling-fire-NNNN.firebaseio.com/key.json but I always get { "error": "Permission denied" }. It is working if I remove security rules.
HTTPS Basic Auth is not allowed in FireBase?
Can anyone provide some simples examples in pure HTTP how to authenticate GET/PUT/DELETE requests?
Thanks!
I am posting this answer only to help other users to understand how FireBase works.
What I needed was to create an application that allows user (with password) to access his data stored on some server using REST. I thought that I could use FireBase to do that.
But. I have investigated a little bit and find out that FireBase uses JSON Web Tokens (JWT) to authenticate users. Token generation should be done on (other) server side, because it uses FireBase secret. So, apparently you can't send username&password to FireBase. FireBase SDK to be used by another server, and not client. Please feel free to correct me if I am wrong.
Firebase authentication when using the REST API requires an auth token to be passed.
See:
https://www.firebase.com/docs/rest/api/#section-query-parameters
https://www.firebase.com/docs/rest/guide/user-auth.html#section-rest-server-authentication
https://www.firebase.com/docs/rest/guide/user-auth.html
If I understand you question, you would like to use firebase purely with REST services, including authentication. For what I understand, if you want to do that you will need a server that generates a token that then you can append to the querystring. So if what you want is a serverless app that uses REST services, including logging in, the answer is you cannot. Correct me If I'm wrong
Related
I have a NextJS web app and I'm adding firebase authentication to it.
I want to make secure GET calls to my server, and was wondering what is the token I should use with the server and where to set it?
Should I use the firebase user's AccessToken?
And should I send it in the URL query parameter (or header)? Aren't both alternatives exposed to whomever sees the URL and they can impersonate the user?
Thank you in advance for the help.
Are you talking about your API keys? if you are they are supposed to be visible, you need to write Security Rules which are pretty simple to use.
Read more here: Learn about using and managing API keys for Firebase
If you want your own server-side code to use the caller's Firebase Authentication credentials to ensure they are authorized for the operation they are trying to perform, you should:
Pass the users ID token from the client to your server over a secure connection. This is typically done in the Authorization header of the HTTP request.
On the server decode the ID token, and then check your own authorization logic to see if the call is allowed.
The entire process is quite well described in the Firebase documentation on verifying ID tokens, so I recommend checking that out too.
We are trying to implement Auth0 in our next+fastify based application. The login page is custom and we want to integrate the login using the embedded login from the fastify server.
I am naive to oAuth and Auth0, I have a few doubts around it:
How do we verify the token? Do we verify the JWT and maintain the token on or fastify server or should we always the validate the token on Auth0 endpoint? I tried calling the userinfo endpoint which resulted in rate limiting. So, I interpret if we just verify the JWT on server instead of sending to Auth0 server. Also we send and maintain the JWT in cookies to validate the client always. Is the understading correct?
Is embedded login safe enough to be used in production? Are there any risk associated around it?
Is the approach correct? Is there any alternative way to implement the login flow? We also need to integrate reset password and rest of the functionality. I have read the SDK docs and it seems to have support for all.
Thanks a lot in advance
There are several options to validate a token issued by auth0, they recommend you to take advantage of middleware to verify the token. Multiple frameworks have their own middleware to check and validate JWT. It's as easy as integrate middleware with your application and perform validation when you need it. Check this:
https://auth0.com/docs/tokens/json-web-tokens/validate-json-web-tokens
In my opinion, it is always better to go with the Universal Login option of auth0, since embedded login sometimes incur into the cross origin authentication issue. Remember, when a user tries to log into your application using auth0, it redirects the user to another domain that differs from the one serving your application. In my experience, using the universal login provides you more information about the login process of your users, and that makes the process of debugging errors and auth processes easier. You can read more about login with auth0 here:
https://auth0.com/docs/login/embedded-login
https://auth0.com/docs/login/embedded-login/cross-origin-authentication
Yep, you can integrate the reset password process, which is almost entirely handled by auth0 itself. As I said earlier, we use Universal Login for our applications since it provides more control over the authentication flow. That doesn't mean you can't use Embedded login, it is a very good option too, but it seems more focused in UX rather than control auth flow.
Check this link if you still have doubts about the best approach: https://auth0.com/docs/universal-login/universal-vs-embedded-login
Intro
So I have read official docs Authenticating for invocation which is about helping developer testing and I got that working, but this approach requires a SA and a generated token. It seems the docs mix up "authentication" (proving identity) and "authorization" (giving access) which is not making it easier to get the whole picture.
I want to authorize Google Cloud Function with the user's ID token generated from Identity Platform. The official Firebase docs says:
"When a user or device signs in using Firebase Authentication, Firebase creates a corresponding ID token that uniquely identifies them and grants them access to several resources, such as Realtime Database and Cloud Storage. You can re-use that ID token to authenticate the Realtime Database REST API and make requests on behalf of that user."
My setup
I got the following artifacts to test function authorization with user:
A local React app with npm 'firebase' and a login form calling firebase.auth().signInWithEmailAndPassword.
firebase is initialized with config fields apiKey and authDomain.
An Express API deployed to Cloud Functions with default permissions, but I've provided the cloudbuild file with --allow-unauthenticated as an attempt to only focus on authorization.
A local Postman request setup calling the Express API with authorization type=Bearer Token and token set to the ID token received in the React app's onAuthStateChanged from user.getIdToken()
The Postman request responds with 401 Unauthorized. Notice it says Unauthorized, not 403 Forbidden.
Research
When reading up on the topic, I came across the following approaches to solve my problem:
Fetch the user id from the token and push it to a custom backend service which does admin.auth().setCustomUserClaims and then do the function request. GC should then hopefully know about the token's new claims.
Also about claims; generate a new token (based on current ID token?) and set claims.aud to the URL of the function. The ID token I'm using has claims.aud=projectname which I'm not sure what means.
Verify token in function code by using firebase admin. But the authorization of access is still not performed, so this approach seems to miss something.
What is required?
I suppose authentication is ok, Google Cloud should recognize the bearer token (?) but I've also read that there's no built-in functionality for this. Anyway, the authorization part is less clear to me when it comes to function requests on user level.
To summarize:
How should we authorize an ID token from Identity Platform to Google Cloud Functions? Could any of the three above-mentioned approaches be used?
I am very new to Keycloak server and want to use it to protect my front-end app and the backend rest API which are also open over the internet. So far what I understand and did is to create 2 clients on Keycloack, 1 is for frontend which used Client Protocol(openid-connect) with access type(Public) and then in client side i am using adopter to redirect the users to Keycloak login page and authenticate and get token. Now for the backend(rest-apis), I have created a separate client which again use Client Protocol(openid-connect) but with access type(confidential) and in Authentication Flow: both Browser Flow and Direct Grant Flow are direct grant and after that i get client-id and client-secret to call Keycloak rest api.
Now i want that when user are authenticated from frontend and get the token and send in header request to my rest API, here i call some Keycloak rest api to verify this token by providing client_id and client_secret.
I am using following rest api from Keycloak to verify the token which i generated at frontend:
http://localhost:8120/auth/realms/evva_realm/protocol/openid-connect/token/introspect
but result is getting like that:
{
"active": false
}
It my be i am using some wrong api OR the whole archetecture to verify and protect my backend apis are not correct. Can someone help me to understand where is the problem?
#user565 I found this medium post that works for me. I believe that you can benefit from it as well.
It basically creates two clients, one for the backend, and another for the frontend. The catch is that they share the same roles by leveraging the client scope, roles, and composite roles features.
Hope it helps: https://medium.com/devops-dudes/secure-front-end-react-js-and-back-end-node-js-express-rest-api-with-keycloak-daf159f0a94e
I started new project. It is small application (playground) to learn couple new concepts. I will create backend API using Ruby on Rails and Single Page Application using React. I stuck in Authentication. I would like to create custom Token-based Authorization/Authorization. I came to following auth flow:
User fill password/login and send to backed using Ajax and through secured HTTPS connection.
Backed checks if user exist in DB. If user exist backend create Token and save to Redis with user id.
Backend response with token to client app.
On client side I will save above token to local storage.
Before every request I will get token from locale storage and pass to request header.
On backend I will take token from header and check if exist in Redis db.
Is this flow correct? Should I decrypt token on client side or It is not necessary? This project is only playground but I would like to do It properly. Please give me some comments if above flow isn't good enough.
I think that you have the right approach. This link could give you more details about token-based authentication:
Implementing authentication with tokens for RESTful applications - https://templth.wordpress.com/2015/01/05/implementing-authentication-with-tokens-for-restful-applications/
Hope it helps you,
Thierry