How to cast from id __autoreleasing * to void ** in ARC? - objective-c

Question

I'm trying to cast from an id __autoreleasing * to a CFTypeRef * (void **).
I've tried:
id __autoreleasing *arg = [OCMArg setTo:mockData];
CFTypeRef expectedResult = (__bridge CFTypeRef) *arg;
[[[self.mockSecItemService expect] andReturnValue:OCMOCK_VALUE(mockCopyStatus)] copyItemMatching:queryCheck
result:&expectedResult];
But the code crashes when the autorelease pool is drained.
How does one convert to void** in an ARC environment?

Answer 1

I do not know the APIs you are using, so I'm not 100% sure of what's going on. I googled and they seem to be part of OCMock. I downloaded it and (without installing it as I'm not interested) I rapidly browsed the source.
I see something very fishy in that code. Here's how they implement the first method you call:
#implementation OCMArg
....
+ (id *)setTo:(id)value
{
return (id *)[[[OCMPassByRefSetter alloc] initWithValue:value] autorelease];
}
So they are returning an id* which is really just an id.
To me that's either a nonsense/error or an attempt to manipulate ObjC internals (even if undocumented, the first thing an ObjC object stores is in fact a pointer to the object class and is therefore of type Class which is compatible with id, therefore it somehow is valid to cast a pointer to an object or an id that refers to an object, to Class* or id*). I have no time or interest in going and studying the whole API to figure out why they do that. They may actually have a good reason (for example if you only pass that result to another API that knows what it's supposed to be, but you are doing more than that here). Instead of studying OCMock I'll try to explain you what is happening as far as I can say (ObjC and ARC).
id __autoreleasing *arg = [OCMArg setTo:mockData];
ARC will do absolutely nothing in this line of code.
What that method does you can see above. Class OCMPassByRefSetter is a simple class that just stores the argument after retaining it, so mockData is retained. The OCMPassByRefSetter is autoreleased and will disappear at the next drain (releasing the mockData and making *arg reference to released memory).
Note that arg in fact points to the isa of the OCMPassByRefSetter (the isa is the "first" ivar of any object, it's of type Class and points to the class of the object. But this is undocumented and may change at any time).
CFTypeRef expectedResult = (__bridge CFTypeRef) *arg;
*arg is of type id which is compatible with CFTypeRef, so the cast is valid. You use __bridge so ARC does absolutely nothing.
If arg pointed to a "toll free bridged" CF/Cocoa class this would be perfectly valid code but you'd have to be careful that expectedResult would become invalid at the next drain (it's not retained, but it's live as an autoreleased instance).
[[[self.mockSecItemService expect] andReturnValue:OCMOCK_VALUE(mockCopyStatus)] copyItemMatching:queryCheck
result:&expectedResult];
No idea what this line does. Given the prototype you posted in the comment above, ARC does nothing on the part result:&expectedResult.
You say it's a wrapper around SecItemCopyMatching, but as I understand it it's more than that. If it was just immediately calling SecItemCopyMatching passing it the result: argument, you'd likely be messing things up. But the name expectedResult and the fact that this is OCMock makes me think this is a little more complex than that.
You'll have to investigate it yourself a bit. But remember:
as soon as the current function exits, the argument you passed (&expectedResult) will become invalid as it's a local variable.
as soon as there is a drain, the value of expectedResult will become invalid, as that address points to memory that is going to be deallocated by the drain.
doing anything with the value of expectedResult is likely do be going very wrong as I do not think that a Class qualifies as "toll free bridged".
I suspect, but I may be very wrong, that you are not using the OCMock apis the way they are intended to be used. But on this front I cannot help you, and maybe you are actually doing it right.

Answer 2

Rather than try and figure out how to cast the variable into the correct format (OCMock is doing some complex things internally), I added another method, to handle the conversion.
- (OSStatus)findItemMatching:(NSDictionary *)query result:(id __autoreleasing *)outResult {
NSAssert(outResult, #"outResult is required");
CFTypeRef result = nil;
OSStatus status = [self copyItemMatching:query result:&result];
if (result) {
*outResult = CFBridgingRelease(result);
}
return status;
}