I am using CLLocationManager to get location updates in my app. Is there a way to determine what the GeoLocation method was? E.g. GPS, Triangulation, IP (Network).
Not really. You can take a look at the horizontalAccuracy of a CLLocation object and hazard a guess based on its value, though:
< 25 meters: probably GPS
< 200 meters: probably Wi-Fi
anything greater: probably cell-tower triangulation
These values are just off the top of my head—to be most accurate you’ll probably want to do some experimentation yourself.
edit - also worth noting is that determining the device you’re running on can give you more information about which location provider is being used. For instance, first-gen iPhones had no GPS, so if you’re running on one of those then your location is definitely coming from either cell towers or Wi-Fi; no iPod model to date has supported anything other than Wi-Fi triangulation; and only the 3G model of the iPad has ever had cell-tower triangulation and GPS.
Related
I've been using some popular taxi-hailing apps like Uber and OLA in India and the same, Uber, in USA. The location of cars, where they're moving and my position on the app's map are always off. So much so, I'd need to call the driver to tell them where I'm at. From this Quora thread I was able to narrow the problem to be in use of Maps API or GPS signals.
The Quora post: https://www.quora.com/Why-is-GPS-in-India-so-inaccurate
The parody video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hjBM-zSq3NU
It is possible that the problem is caused by your device or the capability of GPS in your area. newer phones can use 10's of GPS's to locate themselves this is actually called AGPS. However, older phones use three cell towers (not GPS) in order to triangulate your position. While, this method was fairly accurate it was known to be more than a couple of feet off on occasion. Even older phones, may even use only two cell towers, the problem here that the speed at which this data (light speed) allowed for a very large margin of error which could be your problem. Also, some phones without AGPS use only one GPS to locate, and this may also complicate things for you.
Is it possible to disable GPS without disabling location services?
What I would like to do is essentially dumb-down location accuracy but removing gps function from my phone.
Im aware that I may not have accurate location - and im ok with that.
I just want to know if gps can be disabled and only use cell tower triangulation to determine my (approximate) location.
Thank you.
Igor
Your question is related to programming in the case of testing:
You cannot disable GPS with a iPhone/iPad setting while keeping cell tower location services,
but:
GPS is easily shielded by some metal foil, while GSM is very dificult to shield.
Try wrapping your phone into aluminium foil, you get in every super market.
That should shield GPS, while Cell Tower Triangulation still works.
That way I tested my Gps App.
You can't control the GPS directly. But you can specify the desired accuracy of the location, so you can specify a very large distance as acceptable, and stop updating location when you get it.
Also if you use region monitoring, the GPS is much less impacted (if at all), because it uses cell towers primarily.
I need to read GPS coordinates using a VB.NET program directly from a GPS device connected to the computer via USB (bluetooth also OK but prefer USB). My constraints are:
The computer running the software is NOT connected to the internet. It is a stand-alone machine in a moving vehicle.
I need to be able to read GPS coordinates from the device while the vehicle moves and use the device to perform location-aware queries on a local database
The GPS device can be anything (e.g. Garmin GPS or GPS card without display), as long at it can be purchased off the shelf or over the internet.
The user group for this solution is quite small (about 40 users).
I have already checked out GPSGate (http://gpsgate.com/) and emailed my requirements to them. They replied, and I quote: "I am sorry but we have no product for you." (end of reply).
I also checked out Eye4Software) and tried using their demo product but it does not pick up my Garmin Nuvi via USB. They responded to my questions but unfortunately their OEM product is an ActiveX dll and I am looking for a .NET based solution.
So if anyone has a "home-grown" solution based on the .NET framework, that can be easily duplicated, I would really appreciate it. Many thanks!
Most of the USB GPS pucks will speak a standardized protocol called NMEA 0183. There are several .net protocols out there that decode this protocol, see here for some pointers to get started.
So, if when shopping around you just check that the device is able to generate NMEA you should be up and running in a minimum of time, and at a reasonable cost.
EDIT: a "gps puck" is a GPS receiver shaped more or less like a hockey puck, like this one
For in-car use there are specific versions that can be fixed onto the vehicle's roof
They are pretty common (many online shops carry them) but select them based on the chip that's inside, the popular Sirf Star 3 is still a solid performer, stable and accurate. I haven't had the chance to play with its successor, the Sirf Star 4 yet, and I'm not implying these are the only good chips around, only that I got most experience with this chip.
I'm trying to get the latitude and longitude information from a Windows Phone through the GeoCoordinate Class. When I'm outdoor or under the sky directly, I'm able to get the values instantly but when I'm indoor or inside a room, I'm getting completely wrong values. Is there a way to get my exact location when I am indoor?
N.B. Even when switching my Wi-Fi on, I am getting wrong coordinates
This totally depends on the GPS hardware primarily and secondly on the Service provider's ability to track your device based on towers. So I doubt if you can do anything. To confirm this you can check the default Maps application. If that works then there is some problem in your application. I had seen similar problems on bada OS devices but it was a GPS hardware problem.
Closed. This question does not meet Stack Overflow guidelines. It is not currently accepting answers.
This question does not appear to be about programming within the scope defined in the help center.
Closed 7 years ago.
Improve this question
I assume it doesn't connect to anything (other than the satelite I guess), is this right? Or it does and has some kind of charge?
GPS, the Global Positioning System run by the United States Military, is free for civilian use, though the reality is that we're paying for it with tax dollars.
However, GPS on cell phones is a bit more murky. In general, it won't cost you anything to turn on the GPS in your cell phone, but when you get a location it usually involves the cell phone company in order to get it quickly with little signal, as well as get a location when the satellites aren't visible (since the gov't requires a fix even if the satellites aren't visible for emergency 911 purposes). It uses up some cellular bandwidth. This also means that for phones without a regular GPS receiver, you cannot use the GPS at all if you don't have cell phone service.
For this reason most cell phone companies have the GPS in the phone turned off except for emergency calls and for services they sell you (such as directions).
This particular kind of GPS is called assisted GPS (AGPS), and there are several levels of assistance used.
GPS
A normal GPS receiver listens to a particular frequency for radio signals. Satellites send time coded messages at this frequency. Each satellite has an atomic clock, and sends the current exact time as well.
The GPS receiver figures out which satellites it can hear, and then starts gathering those messages. The messages include time, current satellite positions, and a few other bits of information. The message stream is slow - this is to save power, and also because all the satellites transmit on the same frequency and they're easier to pick out if they go slow. Because of this, and the amount of information needed to operate well, it can take 30-60 seconds to get a location on a regular GPS.
When it knows the position and time code of at least 3 satellites, a GPS receiver can assume it's on the earth's surface and get a good reading. 4 satellites are needed if you aren't on the ground and you want altitude as well.
AGPS
As you saw above, it can take a long time to get a position fix with a normal GPS. There are ways to speed this up, but unless you're carrying an atomic clock with you all the time, or leave the GPS on all the time, then there's always going to be a delay of between 5-60 seconds before you get a location.
In order to save cost, most cell phones share the GPS receiver components with the cellular components, and you can't get a fix and talk at the same time. People don't like that (especially when there's an emergency) so the lowest form of GPS does the following:
Get some information from the cell phone company to feed to the GPS receiver - some of this is gross positioning information based on what cellular towers can 'hear' your phone, so by this time they already phone your location to within a city block or so.
Switch from cellular to GPS receiver for 0.1 second (or some small, practically unoticable period of time) and collect the raw GPS data (no processing on the phone).
Switch back to the phone mode, and send the raw data to the phone company
The phone company processes that data (acts as an offline GPS receiver) and send the location back to your phone.
This saves a lot of money on the phone design, but it has a heavy load on cellular bandwidth, and with a lot of requests coming it requires a lot of fast servers. Still, overall it can be cheaper and faster to implement. They are reluctant, however, to release GPS based features on these phones due to this load - so you won't see turn by turn navigation here.
More recent designs include a full GPS chip. They still get data from the phone company - such as current location based on tower positioning, and current satellite locations - this provides sub 1 second fix times. This information is only needed once, and the GPS can keep track of everything after that with very little power. If the cellular network is unavailable, then they can still get a fix after awhile. If the GPS satellites aren't visible to the receiver, then they can still get a rough fix from the cellular towers.
But to completely answer your question - it's as free as the phone company lets it be, and so far they do not charge for it at all. I doubt that's going to change in the future. In the higher end phones with a full GPS receiver you may even be able to load your own software and access it, such as with mologogo on a motorola iDen phone - the J2ME development kit is free, and the phone is only $40 (prepaid phone with $5 credit). Unlimited internet is about $10 a month, so for $40 to start and $10 a month you can get an internet tracking system. (Prices circa August 2008)
It's only going to get cheaper and more full featured from here on out...
Re: Google maps and such
Yes, Google maps and all other cell phone mapping systems require a data connection of some sort at varying times during usage. When you move far enough in one direction, for instance, it'll request new tiles from its server. Your average phone doesn't have enough storage to hold a map of the US, nor the processor power to render it nicely. iPhone would be able to if you wanted to use the storage space up with maps, but given that most iPhones have a full time unlimited data plan most users would rather use that space for other things.
There's 3 satellites at least that you must be able to receive from of the 24-32 out there, and they each broadcast a time from a synchronized atomic clock. The differences in those times that you receive at any one time tell you how long the broadcast took to reach you, and thus where you are in relation to the satellites. So, it sort of reads from something, but it doesn't connect to that thing. Note that this doesn't tell you your orientation, many GPSes fake that (and speed) by interpolating data points.
If you don't count the cost of the receiver, it's a free service. Apparently there's higher resolution services out there that are restricted to military use. Those are likely a fixed cost for a license to decrypt the signals along with a confidentiality agreement.
Now your device may support GPS tracking, in which case it might communicate, say via GPRS, to a database which will store the location the device has found itself to be at, so that multiple devices may be tracked. That would require some kind of connection.
Maps are either stored on the device or received over a connection. Navigation is computed based on those maps' databases. These likely are a licensed item with a cost associated, though if you use a service like Google Maps they have the license with NAVTEQ and others.