iPad app crashing with no crash log while reading from file - objective-c

Question

The basic structure of my program has the user select an item from a UITableView, which corresponds to a stored text file. The file is then read into an array and a dictionary, where the array has the keys (I know I can just get the keys from the dictionary itself, this isn't my question).
The view is then changed to a UISplitView where the master view has the keys, and the detail view has the items in the dictionary attributed to that key. In this case, it's a series of "Yes/No" questions that the user selects the answer to.
My problem is this: When I click on a cell in the UITableView (first screen), it works fine, the data is read in perfectly, and so on. When I go back to the UITableView and click on the same cell again, the program crashes. Here is the read-in-from-file method:
-(NSArray *)readFromFile:(NSString *)filePath{
// NSLog(#"Path was: %#", filePath);
NSString *file = [[NSString alloc] initWithContentsOfFile:filePath];
// NSLog(#"File was: %#", file);
NSScanner *fileScanner = [[NSScanner alloc] initWithString:file];
NSString *held;
NSString *key;
NSMutableArray *detailStrings;
NSMutableArray *keys = [[NSMutableArray alloc] init];
NSMutableDictionary *details = [[NSMutableDictionary alloc] init];
/**
This is where the fun stuff happens!
**/
while(![fileScanner isAtEnd]){
//Scan the string into held
[fileScanner scanUpToString:#"\r" intoString:&held];
NSLog(#"Inside the while loop");
// If it is a character, it's one of the Key points, so we do the management necessary
if ([[NSCharacterSet lowercaseLetterCharacterSet] characterIsMember:[[held lowercaseString] characterAtIndex: 0]]){
NSArray *checkers = [[NSArray alloc] initWithArray:[held componentsSeparatedByString:#"\t"]];
NSLog(#"Word at index 2: %#", [checkers objectAtIndex:2]);
if(detailStrings != nil){
[details setObject:detailStrings forKey:key];
[detailStrings release];
}
NSLog(#"After if statement");
key = [checkers objectAtIndex:2];
[keys addObject:(NSString *) key];
detailStrings = [[NSMutableArray alloc] init];
}
else if ([[NSCharacterSet decimalDigitCharacterSet] characterIsMember:[[held lowercaseString] characterAtIndex: 0]]){
NSArray *checkers = [[NSArray alloc] initWithArray:[held componentsSeparatedByString:#"\t"]];
NSLog(#"Word at index 1: %#", [checkers objectAtIndex:1]);
[detailStrings addObject:[checkers objectAtIndex:1]];
}
}
NSLog(#"File has been read in");
[details setObject:detailStrings forKey:key];
NSArray *contents = [[NSArray alloc] initWithObjects:(NSMutableArray *) keys, (NSMutableDictionary *) details, nil];
[detailStrings release];
return contents;
}
I've determined that the program crashes inside the
if(detailStrings != nil)
statement. I figure this is because I'm missing some memory management that I am supposed to be doing, but don't have the knowledge of where it's going wrong. Any ideas as to the problem, or why it is crashing without giving me a log?

Answer 1

detailStrings is not initialized when you enter the while loop. When you declare NSMutableArray *detailStrings; inside a method, detailStrings is not automatically set to nil. So when you do
if ( detailStrings != nil ) { .. }
it enters the if statement and since it is not initialized, it will crash when you access detailStrings.
Another thing is that detailStrings won't be initialized if it enters the else part of the loop first. That will cause a crash too. So based on your requirement, either do
NSMutableArray *detailStrings = nil;
or initialize it before you enter the while loop.

Answer 2

Deepak said truth. You should initialize detailStrings with nil first.
But there is second possible issue:
I recommend also to set nil after release, because in the next loop you may test nonexistent part of memory with nil.
if(detailStrings != nil){
[details setObject:detailStrings forKey:key];
[detailStrings release];
detailStrings = nil;
}
And the third possible issue: depending from incoming data you may go to the second part of IF statement first time and try to addObject into non-initialized array.
The fourth (hope last): you have memory leak with "checkers" arrays

Answer 3

Here's what I'm seeing:
//read in the file
NSString *file = [[NSString alloc] initWithContentsOfFile:filePath];
//create the scanner
NSScanner *fileScanner = [[NSScanner alloc] initWithString:file];
//declare some uninitialized stuff
NSString *held;
NSString *key;
NSMutableArray *detailStrings;
//initialize some stuff
NSMutableArray *keys = [[NSMutableArray alloc] init];
NSMutableDictionary *details = [[NSMutableDictionary alloc] init];
//begin loop
while(![fileScanner isAtEnd]){
//scan up to a newline
[fileScanner scanUpToString:#"\r" intoString:&held];
//see if you scanned a lowercase string
if ([[NSCharacterSet lowercaseLetterCharacterSet] characterIsMember:[[held lowercaseString] characterAtIndex: 0]]){
//make an array
NSArray *checkers = [[NSArray alloc] initWithArray:[held componentsSeparatedByString:#"\t"]];
//do a check... against an uninitialized value
if(detailStrings != nil){
//set a potentially uninitialized value into an array with an uninitialized key
[details setObject:detailStrings forKey:key];
At this point, you're pretty much hosed.
The fix:
properly initialize your variables
run the static analyzer
read the memory management programming guide