I was asked this trick question:
Table: Student
ID NAME
1 JOHN
2 MARY
3 ROBERT
4 DENNIS
Table: Grade
ID GRADE
1 A
1 A
1 F
2 B
3 A
How do you write SQL query to return DISTINCT name of all students who has never received grade 'F' OR who has never taken a course (meaning, their ID not present in Grade table)?
Trick part is, you're not allowed to use OUTER JOIN, UNION or DISTINCT. Also, why this is a big deal?
Expected result is MARY, ROBERT, DENNIS (3 rows).
SELECT name FROM Student
WHERE
NOT EXISTS (SELECT * FROM Grade WHERE Grade.id = Student.id AND grade = 'F')
OR
NOT EXISTS (SELECT * FROM Grade WHERE Grade.id = Student.id);
You may use GROUP BY in order to fake a distinct.
SELECT name FROM student
WHERE (SELECT COUNT(*) FROM grade WHERE grade = 'F'
AND id = student.id) = 0
at least this is the shortest answer so far ...
Something like this could work, if you're allowed to use subqueries.
SELECT `NAME`
FROM Student
WHERE 'F' NOT IN
(SELECT GRADE FROM Grade WHERE ID = Student.ID)
Hmm, my homework sense is tingling... Not that my questions have never related to homework though...
You could use the GROUP BY and aggregate functions in order to fake a distinct.
You want to exclude everyone who has both taken a course and received a grade of 'F'. Something like this might work:
SELECT NAME
FROM Student
WHERE 0 = (SELECT COUNT(*)
FROM Student
LEFT JOIN Grade
USING (ID)
WHERE GRADE='F')
GROUP BY NAME
SELECT name
FROM grade G, student S
WHERE (S.id = G.id AND 'F' NOT IN (SELECT G1.grade
FROM grade G1
WHERE G1.id = G.id))
OR
S.id NOT IN (SELECT id
FROM grade)
GROUP BY name
A reason why they might not want you to use UNION, JOIN or DISTINCT is that some of those queries might be slow if you try to force an "optimized" solution.
I'm not too familiar with query optimization techniques but usually if you use some of those aggregators and JOINs, you might slow down your query rather than just letting the query optimizations run through and organize your SQL based on your table structure and contents.
Related
I have problems displaying columns from two common table expression. I created the first table by querying the student names and their mid-term grades and the other table the student names and their final-term grades.
CREATE TABLE MidTerm AS (SELECT Name, Score
FROM GRADE
WHERE TYPE = ''MidTerm
)
CREATE TABLE FinalTerm AS (SELECT Name, Score
FROM GRADE
WHERE TYPE = 'Final'
)
Both of the created have the same number of columns and the same variables. Now I want to display the Name, Score "MidTerm" and Score "FinalTerm", how can I achieve this? I manage to use UNION at the expense of SELECT * only. If I specify
Midterm table:
Name : Score
A : 50
B : 60
Finalterm table:
Name : Score
A : 70
B : 80
I want to join the CTE tables by displaying
Final Intended Result:
Name : Score "MidTerm" : Score "FinalTerm"
A : 50 : 70
B : 60 : 80
it would say invalid column identifier. How do I solve this?
A simple join will handle this:
SELECT m.NAME AS "Name",
m.SCORE AS "Score MidTerm",
f.SCORE AS "Score FinalTerm"
FROM MIDTERM m
LEFT OUTER JOIN FINALTERM f
ON f.NAME = m.NAME
db<>fiddle here
If you have two tables for midterm and final score as per comment in gordon's answer then just do join and you will get your result like this:
Select m.name,
M.score as midterm_score,
F.score as final_score
From midterm_table m
Join final_table f
on (m.name = f.name);
Cheers!!
I think that you are just looking for conditional aggregation:
select
name,
max(case when score = 'MidTerm' then score end) MidTerm,
max(case when score = 'Final' then score end) Final
from grade
where score in ('MidTerm', 'Final')
group by name
I am baffled. Use conditional aggregation:
SELECT Name,
MAX(CASE WHEN Type = 'MidTerm' THEN Score END) as midterm_score,
MAX(CASE WHEN Type = 'Final' THEN Score END) as final_score,
FROM GRADE
GROUP BY Name;
CTEs do not help with this query at all.
You could also do this using a JOIN:
select m.name, m.score as midterm_score, f.score as final_score
from grade m join
grade f
on m.name = f.name and
m.type = 'midterm' and
f.type = 'final';
Note that this only shows names with both scores.
Add student's id in those tables and use it to join them and gather the columns that you need.
I dont believe that create this two tables is realy a good idea,
but, ok, I don't know the complexity of your calculations to get the score.
anyway, I would suggest to you consider the creation of an view for that instead of create those table.
I have a table of data which has students and their subject results in it. The students will appear multiple times, once for each subject they have a result for.
**tableID,studentID,lastName,firstName,subject,grade**
1,1a,Student1,Name1,English,A
2,1a,Student1,Name1,Maths,A
3,1a,Student1,Name1,Science,A
4,2a,Student2,Name2,English,A
5,2a,Student2,Name2,Maths,B
6,2a,Student2,Name2,Science,A
7,3a,Student3,Name3,English,A
8,3a,Student3,Name3,Maths,A
Using Microsoft Access SQL, how can I select only the students who have received an A for all of their subjects? E.g. In the above table, I only want to select all instances of Student1 and Student3, I don't want Student2 as they have not received all A's.
Get all students with grade A except students with any other grade
SELECT
studentID,lastName,firstName
FROM
(SELECT
studentID,lastName,firstName
FROM
result
WHERE
grade = 'A'
GROUP BY
studentID,lastName,firstName) GradeA
LEFT OUTER JOIN
(SELECT
studentID,lastName,firstName
FROM
result
WHERE
grade <> 'A'
GROUP BY
studentID,lastName,firstName) GradeOther
ON GradeA.studentId = GradeOther.StudentID AND GradeA.LAstName = GradeOther.LastName AND GradeA.FirstName = GradeOther.FirstName
WHERE
GradeOther.StudentID IS NULL
One way is using GROUP BY and HAVING:
select StudentId
from t
group by StudentId
having max(grade) = min(grade) and max(grade) = 'A';
I was able to get the results I want by using a sub-query:
SELECT studentID, lastName, firstName
FROM table
WHERE grade = "A"
AND studentID NOT IN (SELECT studentID FROM table WHERE grade <> "A" GROUP BY studentID)
GROUP BY studentID, lastName, firstName
This seems to exclude all students who received a result other than an A.
Can anyone help me fetch the non matching rows from two tables in Oracle?
Table: Names
Class_id Stud_name
S001 JAMES
S001 PETER
S002 MARK
Table: Course
Course_id Stud_name
S001 JAMES
S001 KEITH
S002 MARK
Output
I need the rows to display as
CLASS ID STUD_NAME_FROM_NAME_TABLE STUD_NAME_FROM_COURSE_TABLE
---------------------------------------------------------------------
S001 PETER KEITH
I have used Oracle joins to fetch the non matching names:
SELECT *
FROM Names, Course
WHERE Names.Class_id=Course.Course_id
AND Names.Stud_name<>Course.Stud_name
This query is returning duplicate rows.
If you insist on Join you can use this one:
SELECT *
FROM Names
FULL OUTER JOIN Course ON Names.Class_id=Course.Course_id
AND Names.Stud_name = Course.Stud_name
WHERE Names.Stud_name IS NULL or Course.Stud_name IS NULL
Fetches unmatched rows in Names table
SELECT * FROM Names
WHERE
NOT EXISTS
(SELECT 'x' from Course
WHERE
Names.Class_id = Course.Course_id AND
Names.Stud_name = Course.Stud_name)
Fetches unmatched rows in Names and Course too!
SELECT Names.Class_id,Names.Stud_name,C1.Stud_name
FROM Names , Course C1
WHERE Names.Class_id = C1.Course_id AND
NOT EXISTS
(SELECT 'x' from Course C2
WHERE
Names.Class_id = C2.Course_id AND
Names.Stud_name = C2.Stud_name);
When you ask for unmatching rows I assume that you want rows that exist in names but not in course.
If this is the case you're probably after
select * from names
where (class_id, stud_name ) not in
(select course_id, stud_name from course);
Your query returned duplicate rows beacuse for each row in names it selected all rows in course that satisfied the where condition.
So, for the row S001, PETER in names it faound that S001, JAMES and S001, KEITH matched that condition, thus, that row was "returned" twice.
EDIT Since it is not clear if stud_name is a primary key, or unique (and on second sight I think it's not), you'd probably want a
select * from names
where not exists (
select 1 from course where
names.class_id = course.course_id and
names.stud_name <> course.stud_name
)
Edit II if you insist on using a join (as per your comment) you might want to try a
select distinct names.* from...
Hope it helps you
with not_in_class as
(select a.*
from Names a
where not exists ( select 'x'
from course b
where b.Course_id = a.class_id
and a.Stud_name = b.Stud_name)),
not_in_course as
(select b.*
from course b
where not exists ( select 'x'
from Names a
where b.Course_id = a.class_id
and a.Stud_name = b.Stud_name))
select x.class_id,
x.Stud_name NOT_IN_CLASS,
y.stud_name NOT_IN_COURSE
from not_in_class x, not_in_course y
where x.class_id = y.course_id
Output
| CLASS_ID | NOT_IN_CLASS | NOT_IN_COURSE |
|----------|--------------|---------------|
| S001 | PETER | KEITH |
Only problem is that if multiple mismatches are there in both the tables for a given id, it works for single mismatch for a particular id. You need to rework if multiple mismatches are there for the same id.
Well, I am not sure if I understand correctly what you are asking. I think you want a list of all IDs where the student list in class table and course table differs. Then you want to show the id and the students that are in class but not in course and the students that are in course but not in class.
To do so you would full outer join the tables. That gives you students that are both in class and course, students that are in class and not in course, and students that are in course and not in class. Filter your results where either class_id or course_id is null then to get the students missing in course or class. At last group by id and list the students.
select coalesce(class.class_id, course.course_id) as id
, listagg(class.stud_name, ',') within group (order by class.stud_name) as missing_in_course
, listagg(course.stud_name, ',') within group (order by course.stud_name) as missing_in_class
from class
full outer join course
on (class.class_id = course.course_id and class.stud_name = course.stud_name)
where class.class_id is null or course.course_id is null
group by coalesce(class.class_id, course.course_id);
Here is the SQL fiddle showing how it works: http://sqlfiddle.com/#!4/8aaaa/2
EDIT: In Oracle 9i there is no listagg. You can use the inofficial function wm_concat instead:
select coalesce(class.class_id, course.course_id) as id
, wm_concat(class.stud_name) as missing_in_course
, wm_concat(course.stud_name) as missing_in_class
from class
full outer join course
on (class.class_id = course.course_id and class.stud_name = course.stud_name)
where class.class_id is null or course.course_id is null
group by coalesce(class.class_id, course.course_id);
I am having a hard time understand how the create view, TRANSCRIPTVIEW, manages to set the grade of 0 for those who did not take a course. An explanation would help, the solution and question is below. Thanks.
Student(Id,Name)
Transcript(StudId,CourseName,Semester,Grade)
Formulate the following query in SQL:
Create a list of all students (Id, Name) and, for each student, list the average grade for the courses taken in the S2002 semester.
Note that there can be students who did not take any courses in S2002. For these, the average grade should be listed as 0.
Solution:
We first create a view which augments TRANSCRIPT with rows that enroll every student into a NULL course with the grade of 0. Therefore, students who did not take anything in semester ’S2002’ will have the average grade of 0 for that semester.
Below is what confuses me, how does this work and why does it work?
CREATE VIEW TRANSCRIPTVIEW AS (
( SELECT * FROM Transcipt)
UNION
(
SELECT S.Id,NULL,’S2002’,0
FROM Student S)
WHERE S.Id NOT IN (
SELECT T.StudId
FROM Transcript T
WHERE T.Semester = ’S2002’) )
)
Remaining solution:
SELECT S.Id, S.Name, AVG(T.Grade)
FROM Student S, TRANSCRIPTVIEW T
WHERE S.Id = T.StudId AND T.Semester = ’S2002’ GROUP BY S.Id
how the create view, TRANSCRIPTVIEW, manages to set the grade of 0 for those who did not take a course
The set of students who did not take a course in semester S2002 have no record in the transcript table for that semester. Those who did take a course in that semester do have a record in the table for that semester. The query supplies values NULL, 'S2002',0 for students if they are not in the Transcript table for semester S2002:
SELECT S.Id,NULL,’S2002’,0 FROM Student S) -- this parenthesis is wrong
-- this following where conditions looks for students NOT IN the 2002 subset:
WHERE S.Id NOT IN
-- this next part gets a list of studentids for semester 2002
(
SELECT T.StudId FROM Transcript T
WHERE T.Semester = ’S2002’
)
The solution in your qusetion is ridiculous. The better solution is:
SELECT S.Id, S.Name, AVG(case when T.Semester = ’S2002’ then T.Grade end) as AvgS2002Grade
FROM Student S left outer join
TRANSCRIPTVIEW T
on S.Id = T.StudId AND T.Semester = ’S2002’
GROUP BY S.Id
The query in your question is overly complicated. It is using a union (which should really be union all for performance reasons) to be sure all students are included. Gosh, this is what left outer join is for. It is doing filtering in the where clause, when a conditional aggregation is more suitable. It uses archaic join syntax, instead of the ANSI standard.
I hope you are not learning SQL with those shortcomings.
I've got a table of student information in MySQL that looks like this (simplified):
| age : int | city : text | name : text |
-----------------------------------------------------
| | | |
I wish to select all student names and ages within a given city, and also, per student, how many other students in his age group (that is, how many students share his age value).
I managed to do this with a sub-query; something like:
select
name,
age as a,
(select
count(age)
from
tbl_students
where
age == a)
from
tbl_students
where
city = 'ny'
But it seems a bit slow, and I'm no SQL-wiz, so I figure I'd ask if there's a smarter way of doing this. The table is indexed by age and city.
select
t1.name,
t1.age as a,
count(t2.age) NumberSameAge
from
tbl_students t1 inner join tbl_students t2
on t1.age=t2.age
where
city = 'ny'
group by t1.name, t1.age
not tested, but something like that. I.o.w. a groupby on a join. This sometimes can be faster as the query you're running is doing a nested subquery for every row returned, and the query I posted above (or at least, the structure with a join and a groupby) performs a query on the related students just once.
It might be easier to grab a sub-query that grabs everything at once (vs. 1000 rows where it runs the sub-query 1000 times).
SELECT Age, count(*) AS SameAge FROM tbl_students
Making the full query:
SELECT t.Name, t.Age, s.SameAge
FROM tbl_students t
INNER JOIN (
SELECT Age, count(*) AS SameAge FROM tbl_students
) AS s
ON (t.Age = s.Age) -- m:1
WHERE t.City = 'NY'