Briefly described, I have 2 tables that have 'equivalent' rows in each other. The equivalencies are maintained in a 3rd Mapping table (which maps ID A to ID B). In a view I want to create a consolidated view that shows:
All entries that exist in Table A but have no equivalent in Table B (1 row each)
All entries that exist in Table B but have no equivalent in Table A (1 row each)
All entries that exist in both Table A and B (single row per A/B match)
It's easier to explain graphically...
I have the following scenario (shown in picture linked below):
Current Scenario
I'm sure this is much simpler than it seems - I've been chewing on this for a little while and can't get it workable.
How about just
select a.ID as A_ID, a.Desc as A_Desc, b.ID as B_ID, b.Desc as B_DESC
from Table_A as a left outer join Mapping_Table as m on a.ID = m.A_ID
full outer join Table_B as b on m.B_ID = b.ID
Related
I face issue about duplicate data when join table, here my sample data table I have
-- Table A
I want to join with
-- Table B
this my query notation for join both table,
select a.trans_id, name
from tableA a
inner join tableB b
on a.ID_Trans = b.trans_id
and this the result, why I get the duplicating data which should show only two lines of data, please help me to solve this case.
Firstly, as you have been told multiple times in the comments, this is working exactly as you have written, and (more importantly) as intended. You have 2 rows in tableA and those 2 rows match 2 rows in your table tableB according to the ON clause. This means that each join operation, for the each of the rows in tableA, results in 2 rows as well; thus 4 rows (2 * 2 = 4).
Considering that your table, TableA only has one column then it seems that you should be cleaning up that data and deleting the duplicates. There are plenty of examples on how to do that already (example).
Perhaps the column you show us in TableA is one many, and thus instead you have a denormalisation issue, and instead there should be another table with the details of Id_trans and a PRIMARY KEY or UNIQUE CONSTRAINT/INDEX on it. Then you would join fron that table to TableB.
Finally, what you might be after is an EXISTS, which would look like this:
SELECT B.trans_id, B.[name]
FROM dbo.TableB B
WHERE EXISTS(SELECT 1
FROM dbo.TableA A
WHERE A.ID_Trans = B.trans_id); --Odd that it's called ID_Trans in one table, and Trans_ID in another
As the comments mentioned your query does exactly what you asked it to do but I think you wanted something like:
select a.trans_id, a.name, b.name
from tableA a
inner join tableB b on a.trans_id = b.trans_id
group by a.trans_id, a.name, b.name
Since there are two rows in both table with same ID join will make them four. You can use distinct to remove duplicates:
select distinct a.trans_id, name
from tableA a
inner join tableB b
on a.id_trans = b.trans_id
But I would suggest to use exists:
select trans_id, name
from tableB b
exists (select 1 from tableA a where a.trans_id=b.trans_id)
I have two tables. Say A and B.
Table A:
Id value
1 A
2 B
1 C
Table B:
Id value
2 AA
2 BB
4 CC
Now I write a simple left join
select A.Id
,A.Value
,B.Id
,B.Value
from A
left join B
on A.Id = b.Id
This shows me multiple entries. Why so?
When you left join two tables together in SQL, you are asking the database to look at all the values in the first table's specified column and find any and all that match in the specified column of your second table.
This means that if the database finds two rows of data with ID = 2 as per your example, it will bring both back.
I have 2 Tables, that related with third by one-to-many relation.
For example I have Table A, Table B and Table C.
Table A and B related with table C as many-to-one. So in Table C I have 2 fields like tableAId and tableBId. As a result I need to find a list which includes all Elements from table C which related with table A and compare them to all elements from table C which related with table B.
I tried do it with except, minus statements, but it works incorrect.
Here is what I try to do:
SELECT tableAId FROM tableC
except
select tableBId FROM tableC
UPDATE
Here is my 3 tables :enter image description here
I'm not 100% following what you require but i think below is what you want
SELECT a.ID, b.ID
FROM TableA a
JOIN TableC c ON a.ID = c.TableCID
JOIN TableB b ON c.TableBID = b.ID
I need to know the rows in TABLE A that have join records in TABLE B based a column value in TABLE B, but I also need to return rows in which a row in TABLE A has no match in TABLE B.
It seems like I need a LEFT JOIN and a LEFT OUTER JOIN, so I'm not sure what to do there. I understand how to do each, but don't understand how to do them together.
The schema looks like:
TABLE_A
pk
TABLE_B
pk
a_fk
some_value
I need the joined rows where Table_A has no join record in Table_B OR Table_A has a join record row in Table_B (it can have many) in which some_value does not equal "thisValue"
Thanks.
A Left join is a left outer join. Outer joins preserve one of the tables which is what you are after so good guess.
SELECT *
FROM Table A
LEFT JOIN Table B
ON TableA.Column = TableB.Column
AND B.SomeValue <> 'ThisValue'
All of the rows with a match will have the B information populated all of those without will have nulls in the B data
I really need help getting this query right. I can't share actual table and column names, but will try my best to layout the problem simply.
Assume the following tables. The tables and keys CANNOT be changed. Period. I don't care if you think it's a bad design, this question isn't a design question, it's on SQL syntax.
Table A - Primary key named id1
Table B - Contains two foreign keys, TableA.id1 and Foo.id2(ignore Foo, it doesn't matter for this)
Table C - Contains two foreign keys, TableA.id1 and Foo.id2, additional interesting
columns.
Constraints:
The SQL gets a set of id1s passed in as an argument.
It must return a list of Table C rows.
It must only return Table C rows where a Table B row exists with a matching TableA.id1 and Foo.id2 - There ARE rows in Table C that don't match Table B
A row MUST be returned for every id1 passed in, even if no Table C row exists.
At first I tried a Left Outer Join from Table A to Table B then an Inner Join to Table C. That violates the 4th rule above, as the Inner Join drops out those rows.
Next I tried two Left Outer joins. This is closer, but has the side effect of including rows that match the Table A join to Table B, but don't have a corresponding Table C entry, which isn't what I want.
So, here's what I came up with.
SELECT
a.id1,
c.*
FROM
TableB b
INNER JOIN
TableC c USING (id1,id2)
RIGHT OUTER JOIN
TableA a USING (id1)
WHERE
a.id1 in (x,y,z)
I'm a bit wary of a Right Outer Join, as the documentation I've read says it can be replaced with a Left Outer, but it doesn't appear so for this case. It also seems a bit rare, which is making other devs nervous, so I'm being cautious.
So, three questions in one.
Is this correct?
Did I use the Right Outer Join correctly?
Is there a cleaner way to achieve the same thing?
EDIT: DB is MySQL
You can rewrite it as a LEFT OUTER JOIN by using parentheses. In pseudo-SQL change this:
SELECT ...
FROM b
INNER JOIN c ON ...
RIGHT OUTER JOIN a ON ...
to this:
SELECT ...
FROM a
LEFT OUTER JOIN (
b INNER JOIN c ON ...
) ON ...
You can use an EXISTS clause, which sometimes works better
SELECT
a.id1,
c.*
FROM TableA a
LEFT JOIN TableC c
ON c.id1 = a.id1 AND EXISTS (
select *
from TableB b
where b.id1=c.id1 and b.id2=c.id2)
WHERE
a.id1 in (x,y,z)
As you have written it, it works because ANSI JOINs are always processed top to bottom. Since you need to test B against C before joining to A, it is about the only way to write it without introducing a subquery [(B x C) RIGHT JOIN A]. However, a bad query plan could perform all records in B and C (B x C) before right joining to A.
The EXISTS method efficiently uses the filter on A, then LEFT JOINs to C and for each C found, validates that it also exists in B (or discards).
Q's
Yes your query is correct
Yes
EXISTS should work better
Yeah, you need to start with TableA and then add tables B and C using joins. The only reason you even need TableA is to make sure you have a row for each parameter.
Select a.id1,c.*
From
TableA a
Left Join TableB b on a.id1=b.id1
Left Join TableC c on b.id1=c.id1 and b.id2=c.id2
Where a.id1 in (x,y,z)
You need to do OUTER joins all the way across, or rows that are missing in B will also cause data from A to be filtered out of the result set. By joining C to B (instead of directly to A) you are using B to filter. You could do it with a complicated EXISTS clause, but this is cleaner.