I am doing an assignment (implementing an algorithm), and I wanted to try, this time, implementing tests first. However, I simply do not know where to put them! Do I need to create a new project?
All the tutorials I have found mentioned what to write, but not the general method of proceeding when building a test suite.
I expected Monodevelop to have some kind of predefined structure (like a big "add test suite" button), but I could not find anything for FSharp.
Monodevelop seems to have many tools to deal with tests in a clean and principled way (it does have a big "run tests" button), therefore I thought I would structure my project so that Monodevelop "sees" my tests, so that I could use the tools from the graphical interface. It seems the most common way to write tests is to use NUnit, what if I use something else, like FsCheck?
I have stumbled upon a Github project called FSharpKoans, it seems to suggest that I should create a project called "MySolution.Test" inside a solution, is this the standard way?
What should be the type of the project then, is it a separate console application?
Thanks.
Yes, creating a separate "X.Test" project is the standard way of adding tests in .NET, F# is no exception here.
For testing framework, pick one that Monodevelop supports well if what you're looking for is IDE integration - NUnit sounds like a safe choice. You could conceivably use any framework in F# tests, so I would think what Monodevelop supports should dictate your choice here.
FsCheck is not a testing framework, it's a library for property-based testing that can be used in conjunction with any testing framework. You might want to look into it as it advocates a particularly interesting approach to testing, but it's by no means the only way or the required way of doing testing in F#.
I am working on my first MVVMCross application and I am trying to set up a good testing framework. I have looked at the testing Stuart is doing in his TwitterSearch app but I have found nothing that explains his approach or any other approach to testing MVVMCross. Has anyone come across a good post/tutorial on the proper way to test an MVVMCross application? Other than just code that a newb (like myself) may not completely understand...
I'm not sure what you are asking...
What do you mean by a 'proper way'?
Is this a question about mechanics of "how to write a unit test?" Or a question about "how many unit tests to write; Which components to test; How deep to go; etc?"
For the mechanics:
I personally use NUnit for testing (from NuGet)
I include this in a .net4.5 class library project.
I use Moq for most of my Mocking (from NuGet)
There are a few MvvmCross objects I manually mock - as shown in that TwitterSearch message
There's an MvvmCross base test class which provides IoC/ServiceLocation - but I generally only use this when I need to use real MvvmCross classes - e.g. when the class under test inherits from MvxViewModel
I only run tests within Resharper in Visual Studio
There are plenty of other approaches, including some people choose to run tests on devices - e.g. using the excellent MonoTouch Nunit test runner.
There are also plenty of people interested in BDD testing - e.g. things like Frank, Calabash (coming in Xamarin Test Cloud) and the Windows Phone Test Framework that I wrote - https://github.com/Expensify/WindowsPhoneTestFramework :)
For the philosophy, I have no strong opinion, but I like this answer:
https://stackoverflow.com/a/153565/373321
I too get paid to write code
Are there any good unit testing and acceptance testing frameworks that can be applied to XCode projects? I'm accustomed to doing TDD in Ruby and Python but am new to Objective-C and XCode.
Is the built in Cocoa Unit Test Bundle not good enough? Chris Hanson did a series of posts on Unit testing in XCode, and there's the Apple documentation as well..
The popular ASIHTTPRequest library uses GHUnit.
The advantage of using Apple's stuff is that it will improve over time and will have better tool integration, but I'm not sure it's as easy to use currently.
I'm looking into unit testing and TDD for a Cocoa desktop application and I'd like to find some code examples.
I am aware of Chris Hanson's excellent articles, but I'd like to find through crowdsourcing some examples of actual tests in a code base.
The CHDataStructures framework is fully unit tested by SO.com user Quinn Taylor. It really is an excellent framework.
Edit: The framework is 99.4% unit tested: http://dysart.cs.byu.edu/CHDataStructures/coverage/source/
Adium has unit tests for some of its utility classes and categories.
What frameworks exist to unit test Objective-C code? I would like a framework that integrates nicely with Apple Xcode.
Xcode includes XCTest, which is similar to OCUnit, an Objective-C unit testing framework, and has full support for running XCTest-based unit tests as part of your project's build process. Xcode's unit testing support is described in the Xcode Overview: Using Unit Tests.
Back in the Xcode 2 days, I wrote a series of weblog posts about how to perform some common tasks with Xcode unit testing:
Unit testing Cocoa frameworks
Debugging Cocoa framework unit tests
Unit testing Cocoa applications
Debugging Cocoa application unit tests
Despite using OCUnit rather than XCTest, the concepts are largely the same.
Finally, I also wrote a few posts on how to write tests for Cocoa user interfaces; the way Cocoa is structured makes it relatively straightforward, because you don't have to spin an event loop or anything like that in most cases.
Trust, but verify.
Unit testing Cocoa user interfaces: Target-Action
Unit testing Cocoa user interfaces: Cocoa Bindings
This makes it possible to do test-driven development for not just your model-level code but also your controller-level and even view-level code.
Check out GHUnit by Gabriel Handford:
"The goals of GHUnit are:
Runs unit tests within XCode, allowing
you to fully utilize the XCode
Debugger. A simple GUI to help you
visualize your tests. Show stack
traces. Be installable as a framework
(for Cocoa apps) with a simple (or
not) target setup; or easy to package
into your iPhone project."
I started using the Google toolbox testing rig for iPhone, and its working out great for me.
google-toolbox-for-mac
Check out OCUnit. Apple's developer network has a great introduction.
Note that the Google Toolbox for Mac (GTM) project simply extends/augments Apple's SenTestingKit framework (which is, itself based on OCUnit). As they say on the project site:
GTM has several enhancement to the
standard SenTestingKit allowing you to
do UI unit testing, automated binding
unit testing, log tracking, and unit
testing on the iPhone, as well as
tools for doing static and dynamic
testing of your code.
Note the following comment about user-interface testing:
GTM has extensive support for user
interface unit tests. It supports
testing both the imaging and/or
internal state of almost all of the
standard Cocoa/UIKit UI objects, and
makes it easy for you to extend this
support to your own UI objects.
See their "Code Verification and Unit Testing" page for instructions on how to use it.
I came to the conclusion that GHUnit is the most advanced testing framework for Objective-C. I have done a roundup of testing frameworks on my blog. It is the most flexible in terms of deployment (iphone, simulator or mac os native) and assert capabilities. Because it is based on GTM, it inherits all of GTM's advantages over SenTestingKit but also adds a lot more. Another bonus is that it is being maintained very actively.
I have conducted effort to integrate OCMock into GHUnit, it works great!. You can get the code on github.
I realize this is an old question, but if you prefer BDD-style testing (rspec, Jasmine, etc.) over xUnit-style testing (Test::Unit, JSUnit, JUnit, etc.), then you may consider checking out Cedar. Cedar brings BDD-style testing to Objective-C, now that the language supports closures.
We're happily using Cedar for our iOS projects at Pivotal Labs, and we're actively working on improving it. Any feedback or suggestions are welcome at cedar-discuss#googlegroups.com
I would also recommend using coverage tools to see which part of the code are covered with unit tests and which are not. Basic line and branch code coverage can be generated with the GCOV tool. If you want to generate nice HTML coverage reports there are LCOV and ZCOV which do just that.
I recommend gh-unit, it has a nice GUI for test results.
http://github.com/gabriel/gh-unit/tree/master
The Unit Testing support bundled within xcode (for its simple setup) combined with ocrunner (for some autotest/Growl goodness) is currently my favorite Obj-C Unit Testing setup.
here is a whole lot of them
List_of_unit_testing_frameworks in Objective-C
Sen:te (the creator of the testing framework included with Xcode) explains how to use OCUnit with an iPhone project: simple-iphone-ipad-unit-test.
Matt Gallagher of Cocoa with Love has a very good article on unit testing.
I would suggest looking into Kiwi, an open source BDD testing framework for iOS:
Kiwi
Check out the project's WIKI to start or get Daniel Steinberg's book "Test Driving iOS Development with Kiwi"
test-driving-ios-development
I use SimpleUnitTest works with iPhone and iPad libs.
http://cbess.blogspot.com/2010/05/simple-iphone-ipad-unit-test.html
It comes with a unit test Xcode template to easily add a unit test class. Wraps GTM.
You can literally drop it into an active project and start adding unit tests within 3 minutes (or less).
Specta is a modern TDD(Test Driven Development)/BDD(Behavior Driven Development) framework which runs on top of XCTest. It supports unit testing for iOS and Mac OS X projects.
I hope u can use 'SenTestKit', from which u can test each and every method.