Why is this returning Index out of bound exception - vb.net

Question

When I get to the Read loop I get an index out of bounds error. I think its on the reader ordinal value, but I am not sure why I am getting it.
Private Function Create(Reader As SqlDataReader) As IEnumerable(Of MyObject)
SetOrdinals(MyObjectReader)
Dim MyObjects = New List(Of MyObject)
While MyObjectReader.Read()
Dim Temp = New MyObject() With {
.FirstValue = MyObjectReader.GetValue(Of Integer)(MyObjectReader(FirstValue_Ord)),
.SecondValue = If(MyObjectReader.GetValue(Of String)(MyObjectReader(SecondValue_Ord)), String.Empty).Trim(),
.ThirdValue = If(MyObjectReader.GetValue(Of String)(MyObjectReader(ThirdValue_Ord)), String.Empty).Trim(),
MyObjects.Add(Temp)
End While
Return MyObjects
End Function
Private Sub SetOrdinals(MyObjectReader As SqlDataReader)
FirstValueOrd = MyObjectReader.GetOrdinal("FirstValue")
SecondValue_Ord = MyObjectReader.GetOrdinal("SecondValue")
ThirdValue_Ord = MyObjectReader.GetOrdinal("ThirdValue")
End Sub
End Class
Public Module Extensions
<Extension>
Function GetValue(Of T)(rdr As SqlDataReader, i As Integer) As T
If rdr.IsDBNull(i) Then
Return Nothing
End If
Return DirectCast(rdr.GetValue(i), T)
End Function
End Module

Answer 1

You should just be passing in the ordinal to the GetValue calls:
While MyObjectReader.Read()
Dim Temp = New MyObject() With {
.FirstValue = MyObjectReader.GetValue(Of Integer)(FirstValue_Ord),
.SecondValue = If(MyObjectReader.GetValue(Of String)(SecondValue_Ord), String.Empty).Trim(),
.ThirdValue = If(MyObjectReader.GetValue(Of String)(ThirdValue_Ord), String.Empty).Trim()
}
MyObjects.Add(Temp)
End While

Answer 2

Here my version :)
Private Function Create(reader As SqlDataReader) As IEnumerable(Of MyObject)
Dim objects As New List(Of MyObject)()
Dim ordinals As New Ordinals(reader)
While reader.Read()
Dim Temp As New MyObject With
{
.FirstValue = reader.GetValueOrDefault(Of Integer)(ordinals.FirstValue),
.SecondValue = reader.GetValueOrDefault(ordinals.SecondValue, "").Trim(),
.ThirdValue = reader.GetValueOrDefault(ordinals.ThirdValue, "").Trim()
}
objects.Add(Temp)
End While
Return MyObjects
End Function
Private Class Ordinals
Public Property FirstValue As Integer
Public Property SecondValue As Integer
Public Property ThirdValue As Integer
Public Sub New(reader As SqlDataReader)
FirstValue = reader.GetOrdinal(nameOf(FirstValue))
SecondValue = reader.GetOrdinal(nameOf(SecondValue))
ThirdValue = reader.GetOrdinal(nameOf(ThirdValue))
End Sub
End Class
Public Module Extensions
<Extension>
Function GetValueOrDefault(Of T)(reader As SqlDataReader, ordinal As Integer) As T
Return reader.GetValueOrDefault(Of T)(ordinal, Nothing)
End Function
<Extension>
Function GetValueOrDefault(Of T)(reader As SqlDataReader,
ordinal As Integer,
defaultValue As T) As T
Dim value = reader(ordinal)
If value = DbNull.Value Then
Return defaultValue
End If
Return DirectCast(value, T)
End Function
End Module
Because extension method execute checking for DbNull.Value against already extracted object, we get rid from reading same value twice from SqlDataReader.
SqlDataReader.IsDbNull(index) reads value before checking for DbNull.
Extension method have two overloads:
- One which return default value of given type, if value is DbNull.Value. Nothing in vb.net is default value of type.
- And one which takes parameter for default value you want return if value is DbNull.Value. Possibility pass default value makes lines where you create new object shorter and more readable. We get rid of inline if statement.
Your extension method with name GetValue have "side effects". By name consumer of this method expect to get value from SqlDataReader. So he can expect to get DbNull.Value if database query return NULL, but instead he get null for string or 0 for integer. Name GetValueOrDefault is little bid more informative, so you don't need to go inside method to check what is doing.