One of my teammate just enabled SSL on one of the service that we are using and I had to install a Certificate that he gave me to each of the client machines who intend to consume that service. Now, I am not very well-versed when it comes to SSL security and that raised a question in my mind that
WHENEVER we create a SSl enabled service, do we have to hand out certificate to all the clients
Is there any kind of configuration using which we create an SSL enabled service without having to hand out certificate to all the clients?
IF it is possible then how secured that service be than the service which requires each client to install certificate on the machine?
Also, is there any easy to understand article on WCF SSL security?
Que : WHENEVER we create a SSl enabled service, do we have to hand out certificate to all the clients
Ans : No. For SSL enabled service one do not need to handout certificates to clients.
SSL certificate on server (in this case service) side gives confidence to clients that they are talking to legitimate server.
Clients needs certificates only in case of when service needs its clients to prove their identity using client certificate. With client certificate server (service) gets confidence that its sending data to legitimate clients.
Que : Is there any kind of configuration using which we create an SSL enabled service without having to hand out certificate to all the clients?
Ans : Certainly there is way with which you can make service enabled without requiring client certificate. Check SSL Settings option for website where service is hosted.
Que: IF it is possible then how secured that service be than the service which requires each client to install certificate on the machine?
Ans : Obliviously using SSL certificate doesn't stop any clients from consuming it. Any client who knows service endpoint can consume it. Client certificate is one way to authenticate clients. Only those clients who has valid client certificate will be able to consume service.
Que: Also, is there any easy to understand article on WCF SSL security?
Ans : Check out this link : https://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ff650862.aspx Its WCF regarding security as whole and not just SSL security.
Related
There is a server with WCF client, which periodically initiates communications over internet with many WCF services installed on our clients computers. WCF services and WCF clients are hosted in Windows Service, current binding is basicHttpBinding.
Communication has to be over https with mutual authentication. Company ordered SSL certificate but it is not clear if this certificate can be installed on clients computers (because WCF service is there) without exposing a private key. Binding can be basicHttpBinding or wcHttpBinding with transport or message security but using certificates.
Is it possible to install service-side certificate on client computers and client-side certificate on our server? Should this architecture be re-worked so WCF service is on our server or it is possible to secure somehow this current solution?
Each computer involved requires it's own certificate. A certificate value for authentication relies on the uniqueness of the private key. The private key never leaves the host machine, and the certificate can be used to authenticate said machine (because is the only one in the world that posses that private key). As soon as you start distributing copies of a private key, security is pretty much compromised.
Normally such deployment rely on PKI infrastructure which can create certificates on-demand and sign them with a trusted key.
What product/protocol the certificates are used for is irrelevant. What kind of WCF HTTP binding you use it maters not.
I want to enable transport security for my Self-Hosted WCF service that uses NetTcpBinding with Certificate as client credential type. The client for this service is a WebAPI. I created certificates using makecert and everything works fine in a single PC. But when I distribute the API and the service to different PCs, I get Certificate errors like "Cannot find Server certificate in Trusted People Store" on the client side even though the certificate is present in the store.
Can someone help me where I have gone wrong?
Store your own certificate in a resources file and read that in , then set the client credential to the certificate you just read.
I think there's a gap in my mental model of WCF authentication, hoping someone can help me fill it in.
So, I'm creating a WCF service and would like to have clients authenticate using certificates, and message-level security. I'd like the service to validate these using chain trust so that I don't need each client cert installed on the service. For now, I'm not interested in having the service authenticate to the client.
Here's my understanding of what's needed to do this:
The client needs a certificate signed by a CA that's trusted on the service side.
The service needs a CRL installed for that CA.
The service config should have message security turned on, specify clientCredentialType="Certificate", and chain trust for client certificate validation.
The client config should have message security turned on, specify clientCredentialType="Certificate", and an endpoint behavior that tells how to find the client certificate in the store.
The client makes a request to the service, sending its certificate. The service sees that the client's cert is signed by its trusted CA and lets the request through.
Now, all of the walkthroughs of this process I've found also include a step of creating a certificate for the service. None of them explain what this is for, which is throwing me. Why is a service certificate needed if I just want to authenticate the clients?
You are right. In theory no server certificate is required, in practice wcf enforce you to use one. The good news is that you should use a dummy certificate for the server and also set ProtectionLevel to SignOnly. I suggest to read this article which talks on a similar scenario and mostly relevant.
I have two WCF Services using WsHttpBinding with transport security mutual certificate authentication that are being hosted on the same windows server. Clients that can access one WCF service should not have access to the other WCF service. I need some help on configuring the client certificates on the windows host. The client certificates are signed by trusted CAs and the intermediate and root certificate chain is already installed on the the server. It seems like the service automatically relies on chain of trust and does not require the actual client certificates installed on the server at all before letting the client access the service - this is not the behavior I want. Can someone please tell me how I should be configuring these client certificates in order explicitly allow access to one service and not the other?
Thanks.
That has nothing to do with certificates themselves. When using mutual SSL authentication certificates are used only to authenticate client and the authentication is done outside of your application (this is difference to message security where you can create custom certificate validator). Once certificate is trusted client is automatically authenticated to anything on the server using certificates for authentication.
You are looking for authorization - the step where you define what can authenticated client do with your service. You can either hardcode your authorization logic into your service by using role based security or you can implement two custom ServiceAuthorizationManagers and assign each to single service.
I have binded my IIS7 with a third party 'Server certificate' (Not issued by my server).
I have deployed a secured WCF service on this server with Transport security.
When i try to consume this service, it only accepts those client certificates which are issued by my server (made using makecert). The third party client certificates just don't work here.
To my knowledge it should accept them as they are issued by the same CA!!
Any idea on how to make it work?
Seeing your configuration would help, anyway it seems that the WCF service (not IIS itself) is not configured to use your third party certificate, thus requesting your clients to have a client-side certificate issued by your server.
Take a look at this guide, it helped me a lot when I had to deal with this:
Link