How do I get results of several Insert Into Select statements into one row - sql-server-2012

Question

I have seen a lot of similar questions, but none seem to have an answer applicable to what I am trying to do, so here goes:
I have a table with data spread over 4 rows. Certain values in those rows need to populate another table, all in one row, mapped to specific columns (this to enable a PLC to pick it up).
I created the following query, which as you may expect gives me output in multiples rows (though doesn't actually seem to work when I execute more than 2 part in one go).
How would I go about merging these into the one row? I have had a go with UNION, and had a look at nested queries but can't work it out. Help gratefully received.
--////////
--To change format so one row contains all recipe data,
INSERT INTO dbo.Rep_Criteria (FILE_NAME, BAC, Rev, Tol_Lo1, Tol_Hi1, Eng_Tol1, Min, Max, Min TCs)
SELECT File_Name, BAC, Rev, Low, High, Eng_Tol, Min, Max, Min_TC
FROM dbo.Recipe
WHERE ID = 1 ;
INSERT INTO dbo.Rep_Criteria (Tol_Lo2, Tol_Hi2, Eng_Tol2)
SELECT Low, High, Eng_Tol
FROM dbo.Recipe
WHERE ID = 2 ;
INSERT INTO dbo.Rep_Criteria (Tol_Lo3, Tol_Hi3, Eng_Tol3)
SELECT Low, High, Eng_Tol
FROM dbo.Recipe
WHERE ID = 3 ;
INSERT INTO dbo.Rep_Criteria (Tol_Lo4, Tol_Hi4, Eng_Tol4)
SELECT Low, High, Eng_Tol
FROM dbo.Recipe
WHERE ID = 4 ;
--////////
This might help, though formatting messed up:
Table 1: (Input)
File_Name BAC Rev Low High Eng_Tol Min Max Min_TC
Zeppelin 5636 F 0 6 4.0 1550 1725 1
Zeppelin 0 0 6 15 5.0 0 0 0
Zeppelin 0 0 15 100 6.0 0 0 0
Zeppelin 0 0 100 600 15.0 0 0 0
Table 2: (Output)
File_Name - BAC - Rev - Tol_Lo1 - Tol_Lo2 - Tol_Lo3 - Tol_Lo4 - Tol_Hi1 - Tol_Hi2 - Tol_Hi3 - -------
Zeppelin 5636 F 0 6 15 100
--------
Tol_Hi4 - Eng_Tol1 - Eng_Tol2 - Eng_Tol3 - Eng_Tol4 - Min - Max - Min# T/C's
600 4.0 5.0 6.0 15.0 1550 1725 1