I'm trying to determine if SSO is what I want to use in my scenario. All of our users are in an AD. I have some web-based services that authenticate via the AD (currently they ask the user for a login when they visit the sites). Key points:
All users have a windows laptops joined to the AD.
Sometimes they access these websites on the LAN (AD server accessible), sometimes via the internet (AD server inaccessible).
Some users may want to access these websites through a non-AD computer (e.g. tablet, phone, home computer)
Users use a range of different browsers.
The websites are mostly running through apache on linux servers
Does AD-based SSO work:
if the client machine cannot contact the AD server directly? e.g. the laptop has logged in using cached credentials?
if the user is using a browser other than IE?
Is it possible to have fallback auth mechanisms in place? e.g. if SSO is not possible, then fall back to http auth or cookie auth?
Cheers,
Victor
Yes, if cached credentials are used, when browser requests a Kerberos service ticket, the cached credentials are used by Windows to get a TGT for the user and then the service ticket is requested. This is transparent to the user, so they get same experience as if they were in office, connected to the LAN, and not using cached credentials.
Some other browsers support the Negotiate protocol, not just IE. I am aware that Firefox does, and I think Safari does also.
You might get more flexibility through ADFS which is a Windows component that allows you to use claims based authentication.
The intra/extranet sceanrios are simpler, the interop story is quite good. (Since your web sites are non Microsoft ones).
Tons of documentation in TechNet
Related
After some theoretical help on the best approach for allowing a SaaS product to authenticate users against a tenant's internal Active Directory (or other LDAP) server.
The application is hosted, but a requirement exists that tenants can delegate authentication to their existing user management provider such as AD or OpenLDAP etc. Tools such as Microsoft Online's hosted exchange support corporate AD sync.
Assuming the client doesn't want to forward port 389 to their domain controller, what is the best approach for this?
After doing some research and talking to a few system admins who would be managing this, we've settled on an two options, which should satisfy most people. I'll describe them here for those who were also interested in the outcome.
Authentication Service installed in the origanisation's DMZ
If users wish to utilise authentication with an on-premises active directory server they will be required to install an agent in their DMZ and open port 443 to it. Our service will be configured to hit this service to perform authentication.
This service will sit in the DMZ and receive authentication requests from the SaaS application. The service will attempt to bind to active directory with these credentials and return a status to indicate success or failure.
In this instance the application's forms based authentication will not change, and the user will not be aware of the authentication behind the scenes.
OpenId
Similar to the first approach, a service will be installed in the client's DMZ, and port 443 will be opened. This will be an OpenId provider.
The SaaS application will be an OpenId consumer (already is for Facebook, Twitter, Google etc login).
When a user wishes to log in, the OpenId provider will be presented, asking them to enter their user name and password. This login screen would be served from the client's DMZ. The user would never enter their username or password into the SaaS application.
In this instance, the existing forms based authentication is replaced with the OpenId authentication from the service in the client's DNZ.
A third option that we're investigating is Active Directory Federated Services, but this is proprietary to Active Directory. The other two solutions support any LDAP based authentication across the internet.
Perhaps this might help…
This vendor, Stormpath, offers a service providing: user authentication, user account management, with hookups to your customers’ on-premise directories.
What about an LDAPS connection to the customer's user directory? They can firewall this off so that only your servers have access if they're concerned about it being public. Since it's SSL it's secure end to end. All you need from them is the certificate from their issuing CA (if it's not a public one). I struggled to get this working for an internal web project in the DMZ and there's a real lack of any guides online. So I wrote one up when I'd got it working:
http://pcloadletter.co.uk/2011/06/27/active-directory-authentication-using-ldaps/
Your best bet is to implement a SAML authentication for your SaaS application, and then sign up with identity providers like Okta or OneLogin. Once that's done then you can also connect it with ADFS to provide Single Sign On for your web application through Active Directory.
I'm just doing this research myself and this is what I've came across of, will have more updates once implementation is done. Hope this gives you enough keywords to do another google search
My understanding is that there are three possible solutions:
Installing something on the domain controller to capture all user changes (additions, deletions, password changes) and send updates to the remote server. Unfortunately there's no way for the website to know the initial user passwords - only new ones once they are changed.
Provide access for the web server to connect to your domain controller via LDAP/WIF/ADFS. This would probably mean opening incoming ports in the company's firewall to allow a specific IP.
Otherwise, bypass usernames/passwords and use email-based authentication instead. Users would just have to authenticate via email once every 3-6 months for each device.
I have to begin implementing this for an upcoming project and I'm seriously leaning towards option #3 for simplicity.
I want to have a mixed mode SharePoint 2010 install where intranet users are authenticated via Windows Authentication, and extranet users are authenticated via forms authentication.
There is an existing solution here, http://www.orbitone.com/en/blog/archive/2010/06/23/sharepoint-2010-mixed-authentication-automatic-login.aspx, but I have one unusual difference. In most cases, the Windows authentication goes against an AD server and the forms authentication goes against an ASP.Net membership database. In my case, they're both going against AD servers. The users who use forms authentication are stored on an extranet AD server, and the users who use Windows authentication are stored on an intranet AD server. The extranet AD server has pass through authenciation set up with the intranet AD server, so SharePoint is always directly connected to the extranet AD server.
Is there a better approach to automatic mixed mode authentication in this case?
You are already doing things correctly. When you have internal users on an external farm, SharePoint will look for an available AD server and send the user in question to AD for verification. With the one way trust, AD knows to check the trusted domain for the user in question if it does not exist in its own domain. The whole point of the trust to to avoid calls through the network to your internal domain directly. So technically the users are being authenticated to the domains as you described. If its not working, I would bet your trust is not correctly configured.
I have a project with the purpose of exposing multiple web applications over the internet. These applications are build using IIS/DotNet and Apache/Php.
The internet user should log-in in only one place, and then be able to access any aplication.
What are the posible solutions to this scenario? One requirement is that changes to existing applications be minimum and another is to use ActiveDirectory for user management.
I have found so far the following solutions:
use a reverse proxy (COTS product) to publish web applications to the internet, and the proxy should take care of authentication/SSO
using forms authentication and a domain wide cookie; this solutions requires changes to existing applications and manual log in in AD
create a new application using forms authentication and after user enters credentials into this application, use these credentials to send a XMLHttpRequest to another applications (this will log in the user)
use client certificates, so that when a user connects to an applications, his certificate will handle the log in process; this approach has a problem when there is more than one certificate installed in the client browser because the browser will ask the user to choose a certificate (and this will happen for every app)
Several sites, including this one, are using OpenID to authenticate their users. And of course, OpenID is a good solution to manage user accounts, simply by linking them to their OpenID account.
But are there similar solutions that could be used for desktop applications? I know there's CardSpace, where you create a custom ID card to contain your identity and optionally protect it with a pincode. But are there more alternatives for authentications on a desktop system or on systems within a local intranet environment?
And yes, I can write my own system where I keep a list of usernames and (hashed) passwords and then build my own login system but I just hate to invent my own wheel, especially when I need to keep it secure.
I would recommend that you look into the option of building an STS (using WIF, aka Geneva) and use (active) WS-federation in your windows app. Or if you can wait that long, just use Geneva Server when that is released.
We have a solution that works more or less like this:
Desktop tool prompts the user for ID/password
Desktop tool sends the ID/password over an encrypted (SSL) channel to the server.
Server initiates an HTTP request to a known URL of a login form and inputs the username and password as if they were form fields.
If the HTTP server responds appropriately, the server accepts the client as authenticated.
The target of that HTTP request should be tied to whatever single sign-on system that you use for the web application environment. In our case it happens not to be OpenID but it could be.
I'm currently planning a new web project. Clients are going to connect using a regular web browser and, in case of regular java-enabled cell phones, j2me client. I would really like to make use of the OpenID authentication. In case of regular web browser things are pretty straightforward. However, I am really not sure about installed applications (such as j2me client installed on a mobile device) - regular OpenID authentication is performed by entering username/password on a webpage of particular OpenID provider - which is quite a limitation :)
Has anyone coped with such a situation? Is it possible to create authentication mechanism to the site that uses OpenID from a mobile j2me client?
Currently, I think of solution that users who would like to connect from their mobiles download necessary j2me application from the server web site after they have authenticated themselves (regular browser authentication). The mobile client app could be assembled dynamically on the server with the SSL certificate embedded that is associated with particular logged in OpenID user. After that, j2me client could authenticate to the server without entering any username/password. The data that is going to be stored on the server is not THAT sensitive - considering cases of mobile phone thefts etc.
Can anybody come up with a better solution?
The best solution IMO for what you're doing is to use OAuth combined with OpenID. You're use of OpenID at the RP is fine. But for installed applications that need access to that web site, they should use OAuth to get authorized. The flow would work like this:
User installs app on their device
During install or on first launch, the app has an "Authorize me" button.
The user presses the button and a web browser pops up the web site that the client app needs to access data from.
User logs into that site using their OpenID
Site now asks "do you want to authorize client app X?"
User says yes and closes the browser.
The client app reappears and says "thanks." and now has the OAuth token necessary to access the user's data without the user ever logging in again.