I am working through Aaron Hillegass' Cocoa Programming for Mac OS X and am doing the challenge for Chapter 18. Basically, the challenge is to write an app that can draw ovals using your mouse, and then additionally, add saving/loading and undo support. I'm trying to think of a good class design for this app that follows MVC. Here's what I had in mind:
Have a NSView-subclass that represents an oval (say JBOval) that I can use to easily draw an oval.
Have a main view (JBDrawingView) that holds JBOvals and draws them.
The thing is that I wasn't sure how to add archiving. Should I archive each JBOval? I think this would work, but archiving an NSView doesn't seem very efficient. Any ideas on a better class design?
Thanks.
Have a NSView-subclass that represents an oval (say JBOval) that I can use to easily draw an oval.
That doesn't sound very MVC. “JBOval” sounds like a model class to me.
Have a main view (JBDrawingView) that holds JBOvals and draws them.
I do like this part.
My suggestion is to have each model object (JBOval, etc.) able to create a Bézier path representing itself. The JBDrawingView (and you should come up with a better name for that, as all views draw by definition) should ask each model object for its Bézier path, fill settings, and stroke settings, and draw the object accordingly.
This keeps the knowledge of how to draw (the path, line width, colors, etc.) in the various shape classes where they belong, while also keeping the actual drawing code in the view layer where it belongs.
The answer to where to put archiving code should be intuitively obvious from this point.
Having a whole NSView for each oval seems rather heavyweight to me. I would descend them from NSObject instead and just have them draw to the current view.
They could also know how to archive themselves, although at that point you'd probably want to think about pulling them out of the view and thinking of them more as part of your model.
Your JBOval views would each be responsible for drawing themselves (basically drawing an oval path and filling it, within their bounds), but JBDrawingView would be responsible for mousing and dragging (and thereby sizing and positioning the JBOvals, which would be its subviews). The drawingView would do no drawing itself.
So far as archiving, you could either have a model class to represent each oval (such as its bounding rectangle, or any other dimensions you choose to represent each oval with). You could archive and unarchive these models to recreate your views.
Finally, I use the JB prefix too, so … :P at you.
Related
I am rewriting a pretty large drawing program, now that Xcode uses Storyboards for Cocoa apps, and was just confused about a few things regarding optimization.
Let's say I have a drawing program where the user can draw different shapes (rectangles, triangles, circles, stars; etc) onto the NSView (Subclass: MyDrawing). Cleary these shapes' points will have to be saved in an array for drawRect to recall for later so that they don't get cleared, However I noticed that the more shapes there were DrawRect/Core Graphics really bogged down and when resizing shapes, it was very laggy.
What would the best practice in this sort of thing be? Should I create a separate class for each shape? Should I create a new NSView for each shape? (Although the second one doesn't make much sense to me)
All I did before was invoke the drawinRect method to update certain parts of the NSView, but found that it was still a little slow.
What is the best most optimal way be to go about drawing multiple shapes (while letting the user edit them later on) ?
I suggest CALayer's inside NSView.
So I want to have a view (NSView, NSOpenGLView, something CG related?) which basically displays a map. Such as:
http://dump.tanaris4.com/map.png
Obviously that looks horrible, but I did it using an NSView, and it draws SO slow. Clearly not designed for this.
I just need to allow users to click on the individual (x,y) coordinates to make changes, and zoom into a certain area (to see it better).
Should I go the OpenGL route? And if so - any suggestions as to how to get started? (I was able to follow the guide to draw a triangle, so that's good).
I did find this post on zooming in an NSView: How to implement zoom/scale in a Cocoa AppKit-application
My concern is if I'm drawing over 6000 coordinates and the lines connecting them, this isn't efficient at all.
I don't think using OpenGL would be of any good here. The problem does not seem to be the actual painting, but rather the rendering strategy. You would need a scene graph of some kind to dynamically handle level of detail and culling.
Qt has all this packaged in a nice class class QGraphicsScene (see http://doc.qt.nokia.com/latest/qgraphicsscene.html for reference, and http://doc.qt.nokia.com/main-snapshot/demos-chip.html for an example).
Some basic concepts you should consider using:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scene_graph
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quadtree
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Level_of_detail
Try using core graphics for this, really there is so much that could be done. Watch the video Practical Drawing for iOS Developers from WWDC 2011 and it should give an over view of what can be done with CG.
I believe even CoreGraphics will suffice for what you want to achieve, and that should work under a UIView if you draw the rectangle of your view completely under the DrawRect method of your UIView (you must overload this method). Please see the UIView Class Reference. I have a mobile application that logs points on the UIMapKit, kind of like Nike+, and it certainly works well for massive amounts of points/line segments. There is no reason why this simple approach cannot work for you as well.
I know that the CGContext cannot call it to draw directly, and it needs to fill the drawing logic in the drawInContext, and call the CGContext to draw using "setNeedsDisplay", so, I designed a cmd to execute, but it cause some problems... like this :
Why I can't draw in a loop? (Using UIView in iPhone)
I think the CGContext is very different from my previous programming experience....(I used HTML5 canvas, that allow me add more details, after I draw, so do the Java Swing)
Actually, I want to know what is the suitable to implement these kind of thing in Apples' programmer mind. Thz.
There are three approaches to what you're asking. You can draw everything in drawRect:, you can manage multiple layers, or you can draw in an image. Each has advantages, but first you need to think correctly about the problem so that you don't destroy performance.
Drawing happens constantly. Every time anything changes, there may be quite a lot of drawing that has to be done. Not the whole screen usually, but still a lot of drawing. Since drawRect: and drawInContext: can be called many times, they need to be efficient. That means that you don't want to do a lot of expensive calculations, and you don't want to do a lot of useless drawing. "Useless" means "won't actually be displayed because it's off screen or obscured by other drawing."
So in the usual case, you put your actual drawing code in drawRect:, but you do all your calculations elsewhere, generally when your data changes. For example, you read your files, figure out your coordinates, create CGPaths, etc whenever your data changes (which should be much less frequent then drawing). You save all the results into ivars, and then in drawRect: you just draw the final result. So in your loop example, you would probably have an NSArray of images in your view object, and in drawRect: you would draw them all in order.
Another approach is to create a separate layer for each image, set the image as the content, and then attach the layer to the view. You're done at that point. There is no more drawing code you need to write. Quartz handles layers very efficiently, so this can be a very good solution to a wide variety of problems.
Finally, you can composite everything into an image, and then stick that image in an image view, or draw the image directly in the view, or attach the image to a layer. This is a good solution if you have very complicated drawing (particularly using CGPath). This can be expensive if you're constantly changing things, since you have to create a new image context, draw the old image into the new context, draw on top of it, and then create a new image from the context. But it's good for a complicated drawing that doesn't change often.
But you're correct, CGContext is not like a canvas. It needs to be redrawn every draw cycle. You can do that yourself, or you can use another view object (like UIImageView) to do it for you. But it has to be done one way or another.
I want to do some custom drawing in a NSView subclass where should I get started?
As Jarret mentioned the Apple docs are a great place to start. However, some things to bear in mind:
The default coordinate system used with views is the Cartesian coordinate system where the origin is in the bottom left corner of the view. Most often you want the origin to be in the top left corner of the view so this is where you override the isFlipped: method (the default implementation which returns NO), returning YES:
- (BOOL)isFlipped
{
return YES;
}
This "flips" the coordinate system so that the origin becomes in the top left corner, after a vertical flip has taken place. This can make some drawing position calculations easier.
The main things you'll probably want to get started with are things such as:
Filling basic rectangles (using the NSBezierPath class method fillRect:, along with the NSColor class for setting and using colours).
Working with images (using the NSImage class and the drawing methods it provides).
Paths, where you can draw lines and other shapes (with the NSBezierPath class).
You'll also want to take a look into Graphics Contexts at some point, and working with setting attributes (such as the current colour, a shadow etc) on them, used for subsequent drawing operations.
Probably not of immediate concern, but just a side note, that at some point you should take a look at the Optimizing View Drawing section of the View Programming Guide for Cocoa. Drawing operations should be fast, and it amazes me sometimes how little consideration people put into the performance aspects of drawing, when there are some basic things you can do to make your drawing – and therefore application – more efficient, such as only redrawing parts of the view that have actually changed, rather than the entire thing.
Apple's Introduction to Cocoa Drawing Guide is the best place to start. Lots of examples there.
You should start at the beginning.
I would like to create a custom NSView that takes a layered approach to painting. I imagine the majority of the layers would be the same width and height as the backing view.
Is it appropriate to use the Core Animation classes like CALayer for this task, even though I don't expect to need much animation? Is there a more appropriate approach?
To clarify, the view is not meant to be like a canvas in a Photoshop-like application. It more of a data display that should allow for user interaction (selecting, moving, scrolling, etc.)
If it's display and layout you're after, I'd say that a CALayer-based architecture is a good choice. For the open source Core Plot framework, we construct all of our graphs and plot elements out of CALayers, and organize them in a regular hierarchy. CALayers are lightweight and use almost identical APIs between Mac and iPhone. They can even be made to respond to touch or mouse events.
For another example of a CALayer-based user interface, my iPhone application's entire equation entry interface is composed of CALayers, including the menu that slides up from below. Performance is slightly better than that of my previous UIView-based implementation, but the same code also works within my preliminary desktop version of the application.
For a drawing program, I would imagine it would be important to hold a buffer of the bitmap data. The only issue with using a CALayer is that the contents property is a CGImageRef. To turn that back into a graphics context for doing further drawing can be a bit of a pain. You'd have to initialize a new context, draw the bitmap data into it, then do whatever drawing operations you wanted to do, and finally turn that back into a CGImageRef. You probably wouldn't be able to avoid doing a number of pretty large memory allocations, which is virtually guaranteed to slow your program way down.
I would consider holding an off-screen buffer for each layer. Take a look at the Quartz CGLayerRef object. I think it probably does what you want to do: it's an off-screen buffer that holds things you might want to draw repeatedly. You can also quickly get a CGContextRef whenever you need it so you can do additional drawing. And you can always use that CGContextRef with NSGraphicsContext if you want to use Cocoa drawing methods.