I'm having a severe memory leak issue with my program. I'm using Apple's Instruments to track my leaks, and in the first few seconds after my app starts there are hundreds and hundreds of leaks listed. The problem is none of them seem to tell me where the leak is coming from.
I've gone through all my classes and made sure that anything that was alloced was released at the end, and garbage collection is enabled as well. Another big problem is I tried starting up my app without garbage collection enabled and it just crashes.
Any advice?
Thanks
EDIT: If the source code is needed then I can email it
Your question is tagged with "garbage collection".
Do you have GC turned on? If so, is it a command line tool? Did you call objc_startCollectorThread() as the first item in your main()?
If you have GC turned on, leaks analysis on Leopard will show quite a few false positives in certain circumstances. If you have access to Snow Leopard, I suggest you do the analysis there as the tools are significantly improved.
The clang static analyzer & Instruments are entirely orthogonal. You need to use both because the static analyzer isn't going to find all of the potential leaks in your code. In particular, it won't find situations where -- say -- you have unbounded cache growth or a global mutable set that is rooting your object graphs inadvertently.
Once you have fixed all of the problems the static analyzer finds, then use Instruments.
Try running your project through AnalysisTool and see what it finds. It's essentially a GUI front-end for the Clang Static Analyzer. It will run through your code and find errors such as leaks and bad releases, among many other things. It will then present them to you in a step-by-step manner to help you better understand where you made mistakes.
It's a fantastic tool.
Related
In other words, should a production app eliminate all logging and printing to the console to reduce memory usage (or is the memory usage negligible)?
In general logging take some very small amount of device resources but it is so small that you shouldn't feel any changes unless you are printing a whole book to console ;)
Despite of this, I would recommend to remove all your logs if they are not provide any valuable information to user. Pure debug logs could be very annoying and if someone will work with your code in future, he can call you unprofessional ;)
I will recommend removing logs in methods which are called frequently due to the nature of the app (e.g. an update method in a game loop). In such methods one println may cause noticeable stuttering.
You can use a method for logging which will print only in debug (scheme-wise) and do nothing on a release scheme.
You could keep your logs in debug builds, but you better disable them completely, there have been some apps that printed passwords, tokens to the log, which isn't the best thing to do,
I've recently converted my iOS project to ARC. I have two targets in my project. One is the application itself, and the other is a set of GHUnit tests. I have approximately 200 tests that do quite a lot of work in terms of creating and modifying Core Data objects. The Core Data store used by the tests is an in memory store, and is thrown away once the tests are finished (i.e. it is not persisted anywhere).
When my tests have been running a while (they never reach the exact same point before the error is thrown, but it is always around the same tests) the application crashes with an EXC_BAD_ACCESS (Code=2, address=...)
The output in the console is as follows:
I've followed the instructions here in this answer, and set my main.m file of the GHUnit target to use the -fno-objc-arc compiler flag, but that doesn't seem to have helped.
I don't really understand what these errors mean, and searching for them doesn't seem to have helped. My only guess is that I am running out of memory, but I'm not sure why or how, considering ARC should be releasing objects for me.
I'd really appreciate any help anyone can give me to fix this! If you have any questions just leave me a comment and I will get back to you asap!
Thanks!
Chris,
First, As you have a memory exhaustion problem, you should look at your tests running under the Instruments allocation tool. Remember to turn on VM automatic snapshots. Then you should mark the heap multiple times as the tests execute.
Second, while this may be related to ARC, it quite possibly isn't. In general, ARC apps, because they can automatically release objects sooner, have a smaller footprint than MRR apps. The move to a new compiler with different options may just be uncovering a pre-existing problem.
Third, because you are using an in-memory database, my first test would be to just change it to a SQLite DB. It can have a much smaller footprint. (While you may choose to return to in-memory DBs later, we're trying to find the cause of your memory exhaustion. An in-memory DB can use a lot of RAM. Hence, lets take is out of the equation.
Once you've done the 1st and 3rd tasks above, please report back your results.
Andrew
Well, that question may sound silly, but...
When I run my app in analyze mode or with instruments I get no possible (analyze mode) or memory (instruments) leaks.
Does it mean that my app is 100% memory leaks free ?
No. For one thing, you'd have to run every possible execution path/state sequence in your app to definitively say that there are no leaks by simple testing. More importantly, true memory leaks, where you don't release memory but no longer have a reference to it are all the leaks instrument is able to detect.
However, those are not the only similar problem you can create. You can also easily not discard data that you no longer actually need, causing memory to build up. This isn't a true leak, as you still have a reference to the data in question, it's just that you haven't released it and gotten rid of your reference to it.
You can still find this kind of problem using the allocations instrument. It won't explicitly flag problems, but it will allow you to see if you're allocating lots of memory that you don't later release. On iOS in particular, it's important to make sure that you give up allocated memory when you no longer need it, or your app's memory usage will grow until the OS terminates your app.
That really depends on how well you tested it with leaks but keep in mind that as hard as Leaks tries its not bulletproof, though if you do a through job you can be reasonably sure about your app. Don't forget to also use instruments other than leaks, the allocations tool is useful in picking up on abandoned memory which just Leaks won't point out to you but can be just as troublesome.
Your app does not run when you analyze, instead the static analyzer looks at your code. Regarding the instruments, check that your profile configuration (in edit scheme) is set to debug. Otherwise your app will be stripped out of symbols and the leaks instrument won't work.
you can assume it is in the best state now in which it could be.
I wrote an entire app, and I was just about to submit it to the app store, and in my final testing, I went back and added a few releases to ensure proper memory management was observed. And since then, I keep getting these random crashes. I've tried removing some or all of the release calls, I've tried retaining objects. I cleaned the project. I used NSZombieEnabled and that also is not helping. All this to not avail.
Most of the time, the console says provides no help. Usually the app loads, I put NSLogs in viewDidLoad, viewDidAppear, and viewWillAppear, and they all show up in the console, then it crashes.
Sometimes I also get EXC_BAD_ACCESS (and I know what that means). But its occurring randomly. So this doesn't make sense to me. Thanks for any help possible. I've written this whole app, and spent months on it. So I'm really stuck. Thank you.
Have you tried Build --> Analyze? It will search your code for leaks and other useful things you might have missed. Try that and see if it finds anything for you.
I agree with Rudy. It sounds like you're releasing something that is still in use. I would go back to the version that was working and start adding the releases one at a time til it causes the crash. Slow but effective debugging.
When you say that you "sometimes" get EXC_BAD_ACCESS, what do you get the rest of the time? Where does the crash stack indicate you're crashing? What messages do you get?
Random crashes usually indicate a timing problem. A common cause is accessing things on multiple threads. Are you? It can also mean timing differences based on network traffic.
Make sure the console doesn't indicate an exception rather than a memory violation. Usually there's something in the console that will be useful.
I spent 1 hour on solving a bug: i was releasing an object that I didn't have ownership (ie I didn't send it copy, alloc, new).
The analyzer (Cmd-Shif-A) didn't detect that error while it can detect an object that hasn't been released.
I think it's not normal, is it a bug or a "missing functionality"?
Static analysis is not magic; there are many limitations and the analyser that Xcode uses is a work in progress. It is there only as an aid, it can't totally debug your application for you.
If you think you have come across a case where you think the analyser could have found the problem, then report a bug.